摘要
在1920年代中国的历史语境中,"学阀"一词的语义与概念并非固定不变.1920年代初期,"学阀"虽带有一定负面色彩,但其内涵较为宽泛,指向并不明确.从舆论的"造学阀"与胡适的"做学阀"等论述可见,社会各界对"学阀"的认知与理解存在显著分歧,任何群体或个人皆可将"学阀"标签加诸对方.1925年以后,"学阀"一词的使用频率显著增加,其话语意涵逐渐具体化,且具有一定的针对性.在中国共产党、国民党左派等革命力量的舆论宣传与话语建构下,"学阀"逐渐被赋予明确的指向性,尤以江苏省教育会为主要对象.同时,"学阀"的负面意涵被进一步强化,被描述为危害教育界堪比"军阀"与"帝国主义"的势力.然而,"学阀"的认知并非仅由党派刊物单向传播,而是在既有的地方经验与教育界内部的认知结构中为读书人所接受与体认.至国民革命前后,在政党力量有组织的宣传与动员下,"学阀"话语向苏省教育界全面渗透,深刻塑造了时代舆论氛围,并逐渐内化为革命话语系统与革命行动中的重要一环.
Within the historical context of China in the 1920s,the meaning and conceptual significance of the term Xuefa("academic warlords"or"education cliques")were far from fixed.In the early 1920s,although the term carried certain nega-tive connotations,its meaning remained broad and its referents ambiguous.Debates surrounding the"fabrication of academic warlords"in public discourse and Hu Shi's notion of"becoming an academic warlord"reveal significant divergences in how different social groups understood and employed the term;virtually any group or individual could apply the label of Xuefa to their opponents.After 1925,however,the frequency of the terms'usage increased markedly,while its discursive meaning be-came increasingly specific and targeted.Through the propaganda and discursive construction of revolutionary forces,including the Chinese Communist Party and the left wing of the Kuomintang,Xuefa gradually acquired a clear political orientation,with the Jiangsu Provincial Education Association becoming its primary target.Meanwhile,the negative implications of the term were further intensified,as Xuefa came to be portrayed as a force that endangered education,comparable to"warlords"and"imperi-alism".Nevertheless,the perception of Xuefa was not simply the result of one-way dissemination through partisan publica-tions;rather,it was accepted and internalized by educated groups through the interaction between existing local experiences and the internal dynamics of the educational field.Around the period of the National Revolution,organized political propaganda and mobilization enabled the discourse of Xuefa to penetrate deeply into Jiangsu's educational circles,profoundly shaping the con-temporary public opinion environment and gradually becoming an important component of revolutionary discourse and political practice.