摘要
针对大型活动公共安全风险评估存在的系统性不足、实操性不强,以及风险因素耦合联动、链式传导效应突出、不同功能区域风险特征差异显著等问题,本文以 108 起国内外大型活动安全事故案例为分析基础,从人员风险、设施设备风险、环境致灾风险、组织管理风险4 个维度,构建包含 24 项指标的风险评价指标体系,提出决策试验与评价实验室法(DEMATEL)-网络分析法(ANP)-逼近理想解排序法(TOPSIS)集成风险评价模型.该模型借助 DEMATEL 识别各风险因子的因果关联与网络地位,通过 ANP 求解考虑风险因子间相互依赖关系的全局权重,再利用 TOPSIS 完成各功能区域的风险排序与风险等级划分.选取 2023 年 5 月北京国家体育场某大型演唱会开展实证分析,结果表明:气象突变与自然灾害、临时搭建设施安全性、活动规模与预计人数、基础设施保障能力等因素具有较强前置驱动作用;群体情绪与心理反应、人群流动与滞留倾向、核心区承载容量、安保力量配置合理性、紧急疏散通道状况等指标的全局权重较高.区域风险评价结果显示,核心观演区综合风险指数最高;内环通道区、公共交通接驳区、外环集散区为Ⅱ级高风险,安检入口区与看台区为Ⅲ级中风险.研究证实,该集成模型能够为大型活动关键风险因子辨识、功能区域风险分级管控以及安全防护资源优化配置提供量化决策支撑与科学参考.
Aiming at the problems in public security risk assessment of large-scale events,such as systematic deficiencies,poor practicality,coupled linkage of risk factors,prominent chain conduction effects,and significant differences in risk char-acteristics across different functional areas,in this paper,108 domestic and international security accident cases of large-scale events were analyzed.A risk evaluation index system with 24 indicators was constructed from four dimensions:person-nel risk,facility and equipment risk,environmental disaster-causing risk,and organizational management risk.An integrated risk evaluation model combining decision making trial and evaluation laboratory(DEMATEL),analytic network process(ANP),and technique for order preference by similarity to ideal solution(TOPSIS)was proposed.In this model,DEMA-TEL was used to identify the causal relationships and network status of each risk factor;ANP was adopted to calculate the global weights considering the interdependencies among risk factors;TOPSIS was further applied to implement risk ranking and risk level classification for each functional area.An empirical analysis was conducted on a large-scale concert held at the National Stadium in Beijing in May 2023.The results show that factors including abrupt meteorological changes and natural disasters,safety of temporary built facilities,event scale and estimated attendance,and support capacity of infrastructure ex-ert strong pre-driving effects.Indicators such as crowd emotional and psychological responses,crowd movement and stagna-tion tendency,carrying capacity of core areas,rationality of security force allocation,and condition of emergency evacuation corridors obtain high global weights.Regional risk assessment results reveal that the core viewing area has the highest com-prehensive risk index.The inner-loop passage area,public transport connection area and outer-loop gathering-distribution area are classified as Level II high-risk zones,while the security checkpoint entrance area and grandstand area belong to Level III medium-risk zones.This study verifies that the integrated model can provide quantitative decision support and sci-entific references for identifying critical risk factors,implementing graded risk control in functional zones,and optimizing the allocation of security protection resources for large-scale events.