Study on Grounding Configuration Selection and Electric Shock Protection for Outdoor Lighting Based on Electric Shock Risk Mechanism and Multi-scenario Hierarchical Analysis
摘要
室外照明配电系统长期运行于潮湿、腐蚀、人员可触及、线路分散等工况,接地型式的选取直接决定故障工况下外露可导电部分的电位水平、保护装置的故障切除能力以及电击风险波及范围.本文在分析 TN-S 与 TT 系统电击风险机理的基础上,以 TN-S、TT 以及既有 TN-S 与延伸段 TT 的分段配置方案为评价对象,引入层次分析法(AHP),将环境约束、系统条件、安全需求、经济约束、运维能力与标准政策纳入多场景层次分析评价框架,构建 3 类典型工程场景下的接地配置综合适配性模型,并依托专家评分数据对比 3 种方案.结果表明:在既有系统条件完备的常规延伸场景中,TN-S 方案综合优先权重最高,为0.3805;在既有系统延伸改造场景中,3 种方案综合优先权重相近;在人员高暴露公共区域的新建或独立供电场景中,TT 方案综合优先权重最高,为0.3689;将3 类场景等权汇总后,TN-S、TT 及分段配置方案汇总权重分别为 0.3428、0.3388、0.3184,TN-S 与 TT 方案整体差异较小.研究认为,室外照明接地型式不存在脱离工程边界条件的绝对最优方案,应结合现场环境、既有系统状态、人员可接触风险与保护装置配置开展差异化设计,同时完善施工验收与运行维护措施.
Outdoor lighting power distribution systems operate for long periods under working conditions such as humidity,corrosion,human accessibility and scattered wiring.The selection of earthing type directly determines the potential level of exposed conductive parts under fault conditions,the fault clearing capacity of protective devices,and the scope of electric shock hazards.Based on an analysis of the electric shock risk mechanisms of TN-S and TT systems,in this paper,TN-S,TT,and the segmented configuration scheme of the existing TN-S and the TT extension were taken as evaluation objects.The analytic hierarchy process(AHP)was adopted,and environmental constraints,system conditions,safety requirements,economic constraints,operation and maintenance capacity,as well as standards and policies were incorporated into a multi-scenario hierarchical analysis and evaluation framework.A comprehensive adaptability model for earthing configurations under three typical engineering scenarios was established,and the three schemes were compared using expert scoring data.The results show that the TN-S scheme has the highest comprehensive priority weight of 0.3805 in conventional extension scenarios with well-established existing systems;that the three schemes have similar comprehensive priority weights in exten-sion renovation scenarios of existing systems;that the TT scheme achieves the highest comprehensive priority weight of 0.3689 in new-build or independent power supply scenarios for public areas with high human exposure;and that after equal-weight summary of the three scenarios,the aggregated weights of the TN-S,TT and segmented configuration schemes are 0.3428,0.3388 and 0.3184 respectively,indicating a minor overall difference between TN-S and TT schemes.The study concludes that there is no universally optimal earthing type for outdoor lighting independent of engineering boundary condi-tions.Differentiated design should be carried out in combination with site environment,state of existing systems,human con-tact risks and protective device configurations,while construction acceptance,operation and maintenance measures shall be improved.