Uncertainty of future runoff in upper reaches of Heihe River and its potential challenges to 97 Water Diversion Scheme
摘要
黑河流域作为我国西北干旱区的第二大内陆河流域,其水资源安全高度依赖于上游产流区的稳定性,而这一稳定性正面临全球气候变化的深刻挑战.本研究采用经过率定验证的中尺度水文模型(mHM),使用第六次国际耦合模式比较计划(CMIP6)中的17个全球气候模式(SSP2-4.5和SSP5-8.5情景)驱动模型,系统预估了黑河上游莺落峡断面2015-2100年的径流演变.结合现行分水方案的保证率要求,评估了未来"丰、平、枯、特枯"水文年的风险结构演变.结果表明:(1)mHM模型能高精度地复现历史径流过程(NSE>0.8).(2)未来径流并未呈现出持续增加趋势,潜在的增水效应可能局限于21世纪中叶之前,随后径流趋于平稳甚至转为减少的可能性增加.(3)多模式预估结果存在显著不确定性,主要来源于不同模式预估降水差异;尽管SSP5-8.5情景的降水增加[2.87 mm·(10a)-1]比SSP2-4.5情景[1.83 mm·(10a)-1]更大,但两种情景下的径流响应差异不显著,主要因为SSP5-8.5情景下蒸散发增幅更大[2.92 mm·(10a)-1],可能抵消其降水增加的产流效应.(4)未来面临的核心挑战并非径流量的趋势性增减,而是稳定性损失与不确定性增加.在SSP5-8.5情景下,未来发生"枯水年"与"特枯年"的综合概率将显著增加,特枯年出现概率将上升至25%,可能使当前分水方案在很多年份无法满足中下游的综合用水需求,流域内的用水矛盾可能加剧.这需要通过明确生态基流和时间窗口、加强中短期预测预警、推行用水需求侧管理以及健全弹性调整的流域水分配机制等方式,发展更具适应性的水资源管理新范式.
As the ecological lifeline of China's arid northwest and a critical node along the Silk Road Economic Belt,the Heihe River Basin faces severe challenges in water security.The stability of water resources in the ba-sin is highly dependent on the runoff generation in the upper Qilian Mountains,which is currently undergoing profound changes due to global warming.The current water management framework,specifically the 97 Water Diversion Scheme,relies heavily on historical hydrological statistics and stationary assumptions to allocate water between the middle and lower reaches.However,whether this static allocation scheme remains valid under fu-ture non-stationary climate conditions is still an unresolved and critical issue.To address this,this study system-atically evaluates the future evolution of runoff at the Yingluoxia,investigates the controlling station for the up-per basin,and assesses the adaptability of the current water diversion policy through the end of the 21st century.The physically based mesoscale Hydrologic Model(mHM)and the Multiscale Parameter Regionalization(MPR)technique were employed to effectively capture the spatial heterogeneity of the complex mountainous ter-rain.The model was rigorously calibrated and validated using historical daily runoff data(1990-2009),achiev-ing high simulation accuracy with a Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency(NSE)exceeding 0.8 and a Kling-Gupta Efficien-cy(KGE)greater than 0.9,demonstrating its robustness in reproducing regional hydrological processes.To project future scenarios,the calibrated model was driven by a bias-corrected ensemble of 17 Global Climate Models(GCMs)from the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 6(CMIP6)under two Shared Socio-economic Pathways:the intermediate emission scenario(SSP2-4.5)and the high emission scenario(SSP5-8.5).The multi-model ensemble projections revealed several critical findings that challenged prevailing assump-tions.First,contrary to the expectation of a sustained"wetting"trend in Northwest China,future runoff in the upper reaches of the Heihe River was not projected to increase continuously.Any potential increases in runoff were likely to be limited to the period before the mid-21st century(around 2040).Subsequently,the runoff tra-jectory tended to stabilize or even decrease.Attribution analysis indicated that while precipitation was projected to increase[2.87 mm·(10a)-1 under SSP5-8.5 and 1.83 mm·(10a)-1 under SSP2-4.5],the concurrent rise in evapotranspiration[e.g.,2.92 mm·(10a)-1 under SSP5-8.5],driven by significant warming,largely offset the runoff-generation potential of this additional precipitation.This"cancellation effect"was particularly pro-nounced under the SSP5-8.5 scenario,where the elasticity of runoff to precipitation declined due to intensified evaporative demand.Furthermore,this study highlighted a transition from stability to volatility.The core chal-lenge facing the Heihe River would not merely be a directional trend in water volume,but a significant loss of stability and a surge in uncertainty.By mapping the projected runoff against the guarantee rates of the 97 Water Diversion Scheme,a critical shift was identified in the risk structure of water resources.Under the SSP5-8.5 sce-nario,the combined probability of"dry"and"extremely dry"years was projected to increase substantially in the late 21st century.Specifically,the frequency of"extremely dry"years could rise to 25%,indicating that the ba-sin may experience severe water scarcity once every four years.Additionally,analysis of transition probability matrices suggested an increased risk of"abrupt alternation between droughts and floods,"making inter-annual regulation increasingly difficult.In conclusion,these findings suggest that the rigid thresholds of the 97 Water Diversion Scheme may become frequently unachievable in the future,potentially intensifying water conflicts be-tween the agricultural middle reaches and the ecological lower reaches.The increasing frequency of extreme hy-drological events indicates that the current management paradigm,which relies on historical averages,is no lon-ger sufficient.Consequently,this study underscores the necessity of a paradigm shift towards"managing uncer-tainty".This necessitates the development of adaptive water resource management strategies,including integrat-ing short-term climate forecasting into allocation decisions,strengthening demand-side management to reduce ri-gidity in water consumption,and establishing flexible emergency response mechanisms to cope with the normal-ized volatility of future water resources.