军事知识服务平台
刑法规范的合宪性规制
Constitutional Restraint on Criminal Law Norms:An Analysis of Article 133 of China's Criminal Law
摘要 交通肇事后逃逸加重处罚制度是刑法理论与实践中的焦点议题.现有研究多从刑法教义学内部展开,较少置于宪法秩序的整体视野下进行审视,故有必要从宪法学的基本原理出发,对《刑法》第133 条规定的交通肇事逃逸加重处罚制度进行合宪性分析.通过引入基本权利限制的正当性审查框架,可以发现该制度在比例原则、平等原则及人格尊严保障方面面临合宪性质疑.在行政法已设定行为人义务的前提下,刑法升格处罚的合理性有待商榷;仅对交通肇事罪而非其他同类公共安全犯罪规定逃逸加重处罚,其差别对待与否需经过进一步检验;将"逃避法律追究"本身作为加重处罚依据,亦涉及对行为人期待可能性的合理考量.
Abstract:
The system of enhanced punishment for hit-and-run traffic offenses is a focal issue in criminal law theory and practice.Most existing studies have been conducted within the framework of criminal dogmatics,with limited examination from the holistic perspective of constitutional order.Therefore,it is necessary to conduct a constitutional review of the enhanced punishment regime for hit-and-run traffic offenses under Article 133 of China's Criminal Law,grounded on fundamental constitutional princi-ples.By introducing the framework of justification review for restrictions on fundamental rights,it is found that this system faces constitutional challenges regarding the principles of proportionality and equality,as well as the protection of human dignity.Given that administrative law has already imposed obligations on offenders,the reasonableness of elevating criminal penalties warrants fur-ther deliberation.The differential treatment—where enhanced punishment for fleeing is stipulated only for traffic offenses rather than other analogous public safety crimes—demands additional scrutiny.Additionally,treating"evading legal accountability"itself as a basis for enhanced punishment involves a reasonable consideration of the offender's possibility of expectation.