Reporting quality and standardization of clinical practice guidelines and expert consensus statements in Chinese medical journals:an evaluation and call for improvement
摘要
本研究综合采用文献分析、质量评估、问卷调查及网站调研等方法,对我国中文医学科技期刊指南与共识的报告质量及规范化建设现状展开系统评估,深入剖析其中存在的主要问题与薄弱环节,并探寻改进建议与优化策略,旨在进一步提升我国指南与共识的报告质量,推动医学科技期刊高质量发展.研究表明,我国中文医学科技期刊指南与共识的报告质量总体偏低,尤其在评审与质量保障流程、利益冲突声明管理、证据来源与评价报告等关键环节存在显著不足.调查结果显示,65.08%的中文医学科技期刊缺乏指南与共识报告规范相关制度,79.37%的中文医学科技期刊编辑未接受过相关报告规范培训,96.46%的期刊未在其官网稿约及投稿须知中对指南与共识的撰写作出明确规定.基于上述研究结果,本研究建议期刊出版单位应加速完善相关制度建设,将国际通用的报告规范明确纳入期刊投稿指南;期刊编辑应主动加强相关方法论学习,并积极参与指南与共识的制定实践;同时,应开展面向编辑、作者及审稿人的系统化培训,构建多方协同的质量提升机制,共同推动我国指南与共识在规范性、科学性与透明度方面的整体提升.
This study employed a comprehensive approach,including literature analysis,quality assessment,questionnaire surveys,and website investigations,to systematically evaluate the reporting quality and normative development of guidelines and consensus statements published in Chinese medical sci-tech journals.It further examined the main existing problems and weaknesses,and explored recommendations and optimization strategies to improve the reporting quality of guidelines and consensus statements and promote the high-quality development of medical sci-tech journals in China.The findings indicate that the overall reporting quality of guidelines and consensus statements in Chinese medical sci-tech journals remains relatively low,with notable deficiencies in key areas such as review and quality assurance processes,management of conflicts of interest,and reporting of evidence sources and evaluations.The survey revealed that 65.08%of Chinese medical sci-tech journals lack institutional policies regarding reporting standards for guidelines and consensus statements,79.37%of editors have not received training related to such reporting standards,and 96.46%of journals do not provide explicit requirements for the preparation of guidelines and consensus statements in their official author guidelines or submission instructions.Based on these findings,it is recommended that journal publishers accelerate the improvement of relevant institutional frameworks by explicitly incorporating internationally recognized reporting standards into journal submission guidelines.Editors should proactively enhance their methodological knowledge and actively participate in the development of guidelines and consensus statements.Furthermore,systematic training should be provided for editors,authors,and reviewers to establish a multi-stakeholder collaborative mechanism for quality improvement,thereby collectively advancing the standardization,scientific rigor,and transparency of guidelines and consensus statements in China.