Comparative study of four screening tools in predicting postmenopausal osteoporosis
摘要
目的 探讨北京友谊医院绝经后妇女骨质疏松筛查工具(Beijing Friendship Hospital osteoporosis self-assess-ment tool,BFH-OST)、骨折风险评估工具(fracture risk assessment tool,FRAX)、亚洲人骨质疏松自我筛查工具(osteoporosis self-assessment tool for Asians,OSTA)、中国骨质疏松筛选工具(osteoporosis screening tool for Chinese,OSTC)对北京绝经后妇女骨质疏松风险的预测作用.方法 选取2022年1月至2024年3月民航总医院北京绝经后女性患者140例.按照年龄分为中高龄组(n=69)和高龄组(n=71),中高年龄组患者年龄为≤65岁,高年龄组患者年龄为>65岁.以双能X射线吸收法(dual energy X-ray absorptiometry,DXA)作为诊断标准,通过ROC曲线分析BFH-OST、FRAX、OSTA、OSTC 4种骨质疏松筛选工具的诊断效能、曲线差异性.结果 140例患者的年龄为49~90岁,平均(66.0±10.3)岁.ROC曲线分析结果显示,在总体患者和中高龄组患者中,BFH-OST、FRAX、OSTA、OSTC的评估结果均与DXA骨质疏松诊断结果存在相关性(P<0.05),4种筛查工具诊断效能的比较,差异均无统计学意义(P>0.008 3).在高龄组患者中,BFH-OST、OSTA、OSTC的评估结果均与DXA骨质疏松诊断结果存在相关性(P<0.05),而FRAX的评估结果与DXA诊断结果无相关性(P>0.05);BFH-OST的诊断效能优于OSTA和OSTC,差异均有统计学意义(P=0.006 1<0.016 7;P=0.007 9<0.025).结论 BFH-OST、FRAX、OSTA和OSTC对北京地区绝经后妇女骨质疏松风险均有预测作用,对于>65岁的高龄患者,FRAX的评估结果与DXA骨质疏松诊断结果无相关性,BFH-OST的诊断效能优于OSTA和OSTC.
Objective To explore the predictive effect of the Beijing Friendship Hospital osteoporosis self-assessment tool(BFH-OST),fracture risk assessment tool(FRAX),osteoporosis self-assessment tool for Asians(OSTA)and osteoporosis screening tool for Chinese(OSTC)for osteoporosis risk in postmenopausal women in Beijing.Methods A total of 140 Beijing postmenopausal women with osteoporosis in Civil Aviation General Hospital from January 2022 to March 2024 were selected,and were divided into middle-aged and high-aged groups(n=69)and high-aged groups(n=71)according to age,the patients in middle-aged and high-aged groups were≤65 years old,while those in high-aged groups were>65 years old.and dual energy X-ray absorptiometry(DXA)was used as the diagnostic criterion.The diagnostic efficiency and curve differences of BFH-OST,FRAX,OSTA and OSTC were analyzed by ROC curve.Results The 140 patients ranged in age from 49 to 90 years,with an average of(66.0±10.3)years.ROC curve analysis showed that the evaluation results of BFH-OST,FRAX,OSTA and OSTC were all correlated with the diagnosis results of DXA osteoporosis(P<0.05),and there was no statistical difference in the diagnostic efficiency of the four screening tools(P>0.0083).In the elderly patients,the evaluation results of BFH-OST,OSTA and OSTC were correlated with the diagnosis results of DXA osteoporosis(P<0.05),while the evaluation results of FRAX were not correlated with the diagnosis results of DXA(P>0.05).The diagnostic efficiency of BFH-OST was better than that of OSTA and OSTC,and the difference was statistically significant(P=0.006 1<0.016 7;P=0.007 9<0.025).Conclusions BFH-OST,FRAX,OSTA,and OSTC can all predict the risk of osteoporosis in postmenopausal women in Beijing.For elderly patients over 65 years old,the evaluation results of FRAX are not related to the diagnosis results of DXA osteoporosis,and the diagnostic efficiency of BFH-OST is better than that of OSTA and OSTC.