证券群体诉讼:主体集体化与判决效力扩张
Securities Group Litigation:Aggregation of Parties and Expansion of Judgment Effect
摘要
与证券权利主体分散的独立诉讼相比,证券群体性诉讼是解决相同证券侵权行为引发的群体性纠纷最有效率的诉讼方式.普通证券代表人诉讼与特别证券代表人诉讼的二元结构具有我国自己的特色,但就众多证券权利人维权的便利和高效而言还存在某些不足.未能通过权利登记方式参与证券代表人诉讼的权利人如果要想获得执行根据就需要另行提起诉讼.因此,更有效的方式是通过权利主体的集体化,使得因为相同侵权行为致损的受害人均自动成为该拟制集体的成员,除非声明退出该集体.这种判决效力扩张不同于法院对代表人诉讼生效判决的适用,其法理是拟制权利主体的集体化.与此不同,另行诉讼中法院作出的直接适用代表人诉讼生效判决的裁定毕竟不能发生审结诉讼的效力.在有先行的证券诉讼(包括代表人诉讼和非代表人诉讼)判决生效之后,侵权事实基本相同的后行证券诉讼是否可以或应当直接适用前诉的生效判决,并终结诉讼系属,需要法律明确加以规定.鉴于证券群体性诉讼的复杂性,制定单独《证券群体诉讼法》应当尽早提上立法日程.
Compared to independent lawsuits brought by dispersed holders of securities rights,securities collective litigation represents the most efficient procedural mechanism for resolving mass disputes arising from identical securities torts.The dual structure of ordinary and special securities representative actions embodies distinctive Chinese characteristics.However,from the perspective of convenience and efficiency for numerous rights-holders seeking redress,certain shortcomings remain.Rights-holders who fail to participate in a securities representative action through rights registration must initiate separate lawsuits to obtain an enforceable title.Consequently,a more effective approach lies in the collectivization of rights-holders,whereby all victims of the same tort automatically become members of this constructed collective unless they expressly opt out.This expansion of judgment effects differs from a court's application of a final judgment from a representative action.Its legal rationale is based on the collectivization of the constructed rights-holders.In contrast,a ruling in a separate lawsuit that directly applies the final judgment of a representative action cannot produce the effect of concluding that litigation.Following the effectiveness of a prior securities judgment(whether from a representative or non-representative action),the law must clearly stipulate whether and how subsequent securities litigation involving substantially identical tort facts may or should directly apply the prior final judgment and thereby terminate the pending proceedings.Given the complexity of securities collective litigation,the enactment of a separate Securities Collective Litigation Law should be placed on the legislative agenda at the earliest opportunity.
年,卷(期):
2026, (5)
机标分类号:
D922.5
F249.26
F832
在线出版日期:
2026年10月26日
基金项目:
21SFB2016:国家法治与法学理论研究项目,