军事知识服务平台
中国式证券骚扰诉讼的破题与因应
The Causes and Solutions of Chinese Securities Frivolous Suits
摘要 投资者提起非诚信诉讼或者并无可靠事实依据的诉讼具有明显的负外部性,成本远大于收益,称为证券骚扰诉讼,应当予以限制.中国式证券骚扰诉讼包括以下四种类型:"投石问路"型、"捕风捉影"型、"张冠李戴"型以及"一网打尽"型.对此,应当完善审判机制和立案审查:一是,统一各地方法院实践,在全国范围内将示范判决机制作为审理证券诉讼的基本模式;二是,加强法院在立案阶段对于投资者证据的审查,针对不同的被告类型与主观要件,要求投资者提供不同的证据,将明显缺乏胜诉可能性的案件及早过滤掉,以节省被告和法院的成本;三是,在法院释明的情况下,如果投资者依旧不提供法院所要求的证据,执意提起诉讼并败诉,法院应当判决投资者负担对方的诉讼成本.
Abstract:
Lawsuits initiated by investors without reliable factual basis or in violation of litigation integrity are referred to as securities frivolous suits.From the perspective of social costs,the costs of such lawsuits for investors far outweigh the benefits,resulting in negative externalities that should be restricted.The four types of securities frivolous suits with Chinese characteristics are:"testing the waters"type lawsuits,"groundless"type lawsuits,"misattribution"type lawsuits,and"all-encompassing"type lawsuits.The main solution is to strengthen courts' reviews of these four types of lawsuits by the way of improving the trial mechanism and its acceptance and review.First,unify judicial practices across regions and establish a model judgment mechanism as the standard for securities litigation nationwide.Second,enhance the review of investor evidence by courts at the filing stage,set different evidentiary requirements based on the type and subjective state of the defendant,and filter out cases with little chance of success early so as to save costs for both defendants and courts.Third,if investors still refuse to provide the required evidence despite court guidance and insist on filing a lawsuit,and if they lose,the court shall order the investor to bear the opposing party's litigation costs.
刊 名 财经法学
年,卷(期): 2026, (5)
机标分类号: D925.1 F832.51 F279.246
在线出版日期: 2026年10月26日