Tiered Market Access Regulation for Public Data Operators:A Contestable Market Theory Perspective
摘要
公共数据授权运营是公共数据要素市场化配置的重要方式.当前全国各省市开展的公共数据授权运营实践,多以行政授权代替市场竞争,偏离了数据要素市场开放共享的发展规律.可竞争市场理论从加强沉没成本管理的角度强调降低制度性进入壁垒、放松政府管制,适配公共数据市场的竞争特性.基于此,应区分公共数据基础设施层和开发利用层的功能定位,分层构建公平开放的准入规则体系,以有效调节数据安全与市场效率、规模经济与有效竞争的平衡度.其中,基础设施层具有较强的公共性和规模经济属性,可采取政府采购或特许经营模式,同时需通过公平竞争审查激活竞争性授权机制,保障民间资本的公平进入.而开发层更具可竞争性,应以动态竞争维护为导向,强化反垄断法规制对数据壁垒、技术壁垒及排他性行为的约束,促进公共数据市场竞争与创新.
Public data authorized operation has become an important mechanism for the market-oriented allocation of public data elements and possesses clear normative justification.However,current practices of public data authorized operation across various provinces and municipalities in China have not clearly delineated the boundary between government regulation and market competition,which directly affects the design and effectiveness of market access mechanisms.Contestable market theory emphasizes reducing institutional entry barriers and relaxing government regulation through sunk cost management,thereby aligning with the competitive characteristics of public data markets.Accordingly,a tiered and open market access framework should be established by distinguishing between the infrastructure layer and the development-and-utilization layer,so as to balance data security,market efficiency,and effective competition.In this framework,the infrastructure layer possesses strong public-interest and economies-of-scale characteristics,and is typically organized through government procurement or concession arrangements.At the same time,fair competition review should be introduced to ensure competitive authorization procedures and to constrain excessive governmental intervention.By contrast,the development and application layer is more contestable and should be primarily governed through ex post antitrust regulation in order to lower entry barriers and stimulate market vitality.