商业银行绿色信贷义务的规范路径、法律属性与赔偿责任
The Regulatory Approach,Legal Nature and Compensation Liability of Commercial Banks' Green Lending Obligation
摘要
我国相关法律和政策构建了商业银行绿色信贷义务的制度基础,但尚缺乏明确的法律规范依据,尤其是未能明确其法律属性及赔偿责任.从法律规范构造与实践效果角度而言,强化商业银行违反绿色信贷义务的赔偿责任,应重于激励其向绿色行业及企业放贷,并以合理方式推动绿色信贷义务转化为具体的法律规范.绿色信贷义务的法律属性不能只归结为商业银行在"明知"状态下的环境侵权责任,而应包括在"应知"状态下,将其定位于商业银行对借款人使用贷款资金从事生产经营活动时不得污染环境、破坏生态的监督义务.商业银行对借款人监督义务的主要内容除了贷款前的调查义务和贷款后的监测义务,还应包括还款后的评价义务.商业银行因过失而未履行对借款人监督义务的,应根据主观过错、客观行为、损害结果、因果关系等因素承担类型化的赔偿责任,同时应明确商业银行的免责事由,并引入责任保险机制以实现风险分担.
China's relevant laws and policies have established the institutional foundation for the commercial banks' green lending obligation,yet there still remains lacking clear legal provision for this obligation,particularly regarding its legal nature and compensation liability.From the perspectives of the constitution of legal norm and the effect of practical implementation,strengthening the compensation liability for violation of green lending obligation should prioritize incentivizing lending to green industries and enterprises.Besides,it is important to reasonably transform the obligation into concrete legal norms.The legal nature of green lending obligation cannot be simply reduced to environmental tort liability under the"have known"circumstance of the banks.Instead,it should also include the"should have known"circumstance of the banks,in which the attribute of banks' green lending obligation should be defined as the banks' supervisory obligation to ensure borrowers not pollute the environment or damage ecosystem when utilizing the loans in their businesses.Beyond pre-loan due diligence and post-loan monitoring,banks' supervisory obligations also encompass post-repayment evaluation.When the banks fail to fulfill these obligations due to negligence,they shall bear categorized compensation liabilities based on factors such as subjective faults,objective actions,damage outcomes,and causality relationships.Additionally,clear exemptions from compensation liability should be established,and the liability insurance mechanism should be introduced to facilitate risk sharing.
年,卷(期):
2026, (5)
机标分类号:
D912.3
F832.4
F284
在线出版日期:
2026年10月26日
基金项目:
20&ZD197:国家社会科学基金,