军事知识服务平台
自动化行政中裁量基准技术适用及其逸脱调适机制
The Technical Application of Discretion Benchmarks in Automated Administration and Its Deviation-adjustment Mechanism
摘要 自动化行政中裁量基准的技术适用极大提升了行政效率,但其预置逻辑的刚性复现则易引发规则普适性与案件特殊性的冲突.依技术路线划分,裁量基准的技术适用包括文本转译型、参数演绎型、情景识别型三种形态.作为机器裁量的一种类型,其法治风险兼具一般机器裁量的共通性与自身技术路径的殊异性.为此,应以剖析裁量基准技术适用的"形式裁量方法论"内核为基础,重释逸脱在实现方式、审查对象与目标范围方面的全新原理.构建以"人类中心"为价值遵循的逸脱调适机制,推动逻辑之治复归于法律之治.申言之,具体制度展开应结合三种裁量基准的技术适用类型,兼顾两类法治风险的特征需求,通过设置条款媒介、明确启动阈值、细化运行流程、强化监督保障等微观措施的建构,弥合既有理论现实与规则治理目标的错配.
Abstract:
The technical application of discretion benchmarks in automated administration has greatly improved administrative efficiency,yet the rigid reproduction of its embedded logic tends to generate tension between the generality of rules and the particularity of cases.Classified by technical route,the technical application of discretion benchmarks comprises three types:text-transcoding,parameter-derivation,and scenario-recognition.As a form of machine discretion,its rule-of-law risks combine both the common risks of machine decision-making in general and the distinctive risks arising from its own technical pathways.Accordingly,on the basis of analyzing the inner logic of the"formal discretion methodology"embodied in the technical application of discretion benchmarks,it is necessary to reinterpret the novel rationale of deviation in terms of its mode of realization,object of review,and scope of objectives.On this basis,a deviation-adjustment mechanism guided by human-centeredness should be constructed so as to restore governance by logic to the rule of law.More specifically,the institutional design should be tailored to the three types of technical application of discretion benchmarks and should respond to the distinctive requirements arising from the two categories of rule-of-law risks.Through such micro-level measures as using clauses as the institutional vehicle for deviation,clarifying initiation thresholds,refining operational procedures,and strengthening supervisory safeguards,the deviation-adjustment mechanism should bridge the gap between existing theoretical and practical realities and the objectives of rule-based governance.
刊 名 财经法学
年,卷(期): 2026, (5)
机标分类号: D631 D921.8 TP311
在线出版日期: 2026年10月26日
基金项目: 25JZD024:教育部哲学社会科学研究项目,