军事知识服务平台
数字公共服务算法歧视规制研究
Regulating Algorithmic Discrimination in Digital Public Services:Focusing on the Protection of Digital Accessibility Rights for Persons with Disabilities
摘要 数字公共服务的算法化转型在提升行政效率的同时,也可能通过数据代表性不足、交互设计障碍、身份认证失败与自动化救济缺失,对残疾人形成结构性排斥.与传统公共服务障碍不同,数字公共服务中的算法歧视通常不表现为以"残疾"为标准的直接排除,而是以"标准用户"假设为前提,通过默认交互流程与自动化风险控制,将视力、听力、言语、肢体、智力与精神残疾人识别并标记为"异常用户"、"失败用户"或"无法处理对象".研究以保障残疾人数字可及权为中心,提出"标准用户偏离型算法排斥"的分析框架,通过分析公共服务App、医疗急救和就医挂号等本土无障碍治理案例,揭示算法排斥在数据、设计、运行与救济环节的生成机制,并比较欧盟、美国与韩国在数字无障碍、政府数字服务可及性与人工智能风险治理方面的制度经验及其对中国的适配边界.研究认为,公共部门不得以技术中立或效率提升为由减轻无障碍保障责任,应将数字可及性、合理便利与实质平等贯穿公共算法治理全过程,通过事前影响评估、无障碍采购验收、替代认证、人工复核、低成本申诉与检察公益诉讼监督等机制,构建面向残疾人友好的数字公共服务算法规制体系.
Abstract:
The algorithmic transformation of digital public services,while enhancing administrative efficiency,may also generate structural exclusion against persons with disabilities through insufficient data representativeness,inaccessible interaction design,authentication failures,and the absence of effective automated remedies.Unlike traditional barriers in public service delivery,algorithmic discrimination in digital public services rarely manifests as explicit exclusion based on"disability".Instead,it operates on the implicit assumption of a"standard user",embedding exclusion within default interaction processes and automated risk-control mechanisms that identify and mark persons with visual,hearing,speech,physical,intellectual,and psychosocial disabilities as"abnormal users","failed users",or"unprocessable cases".Centering on the protection of digital accessibility rights for persons with disabilities,the study proposes an analytical framework of"standard-user-deviation algorithmic exclusion",analyzes domestic governance cases involving the accessibility of public-service applications,emergency medical systems,and medical appointment platforms,and examines the mechanisms through which exclusion emerges across the stages of data,design,operation,and remedy.The study further compares regulatory approaches in the European Union,the United States,and the Republic of Korea concerning digital accessibility,government digital-service accessibility,and AI risk governance,and assesses their adaptability to the Chinese context.It argues that public authorities should not invoke technological neutrality or efficiency gains to dilute accessibility obligations.Instead,digital accessibility,reasonable accommodation,and substantive equality should be embedded throughout the lifecycle of public algorithmic governance.Through mechanisms of ex ante impact assessment,accessibility-oriented procurement and acceptance standards,alternative authentication mechanisms,human review,low-cost complaint channels,and procuratorial public-interest litigation supervision,a regulatory framework for disability-friendly digital public services can be constructed.
刊 名 残疾人研究
年,卷(期): 2026, (4)
分类号: D669.69 TP39
机标分类号: D926.3 D035-39 TP393.08
在线出版日期: 2026年10月14日