Urban Low-Altitude Governance in China from the Perspective of Multi-Level Governance:A Case Study of Shenzhen
摘要
低空经济是培育发展新质生产力的战略性新兴产业,关乎国家空域安全和国际产业竞争,这一新业态衍生出跨层级、跨部门、跨主体的治理议题.本文立足央地授权的制度前提,审慎借鉴多层治理理论,构建"垂直联动、水平协同、适应性调适"三维分析框架,以深圳低空治理实践为案例展开研究.结果表明,我国城市低空治理形成本土多层治理模式:在垂直维度,形成了中央统筹底线规制、省居中协调、市规则探索、区场景实践的跨层级政府合作网络;在水平维度,通过打破政府内部壁垒与吸纳社会多元主体,构建知识互补、风险共担的协同共治格局;在适应性调适层面,依靠地方立法固化协商机制、数字底座支撑双向互动,通过基层试错、政企共建规则、央地经验互鉴反哺的社会学习机制,推动实践经验转化为正式制度,动态统筹高水平安全与高质量发展.本研究修正西方多层治理理论的固有预设,为统筹低空经济发展与安全、完善城市立体空间治理提供经验与学理参考.
The low-altitude economy is a strategic emerging industry for cultivating and developing new quality productive forces,and is related to national airspace security and international industrial competition.This new business form gives rise to cross-tier,cross-departmental,and multi-actor governance issues.Based on the institutional premise of central-to-local authorization and drawing cautiously on multi-level governance theory,this paper constructs a three-dimensional analytical framework of"vertical interconnection,horizontal synergy,and adaptive governance,"and takes Shenzhen's low-altitude governance practice as a case for study.The results show that urban low-altitude governance in China has formed an indigenous multi-level governance model.Vertically,a cross-tier intergovernmental cooperation network has emerged,in which central authorities coordinate baseline regulation,provinces play a coordinating role,municipalities explore rules,and districts practice scenarios.Horizontally,breaking down internal governmental silos and engaging diverse social actors fosters a collaborative co-governance pattern characterized by complementary knowledge and shared risk.At the level of adaptive governance,local legislation consolidates consultation mechanisms,and the digital foundation supports two-way interaction.Through social learning mechanisms involving grassroots trial and error,government-enterprise co-construction of rules,and mutual learning and feedback between central and local levels,practical experience is translated into formal institutions,dynamically balancing high-level security and high-quality development.This study revises the inherent presuppositions of Western multi-level governance theory,providing empirical and theoretical references for coordinating the development and security of the low-altitude economy and improving urban three-dimensional spatial governance.