RESEARCH ON THE SYNERGISTIC EFFECTS OF URBAN REGENERATION POLICIES:A QUANTITATIVE TEXTUAL ANALYSIS BASED ON THE BERTOPIC MODEL
摘要
城市更新作为存量时代的重要治理策略,在迭代提升进程中面临着多领域交织的政策协同挑战.为系统探讨我国城市更新政策的协同效应,本研究创新性地构建了"时空-内容-主体"三维协同分析框架,运用BERTopic(Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers Topic)模型,从主题挖掘、时空协同、内容协同和主体协同四个关键维度,对2015-2025年间中央与地方政府颁布的269份城市更新政策文本进行了量化剖析.研究表明:(1)城市更新政策主要涵盖14个主题,演进历程可划分为启动、拓展和全面实施三个阶段;(2)政策主题有效聚类为基础设施更新、社会经济环境可持续和人居环境优化与城市功能完善三大主要类别,但在城镇规划等领域存在重叠,且在利益共享、市场激励和立法等维度存在缺失;(3)尽管地方政府与中央政府政策内容协同度较高,但仍呈现出政府单部门主导等瓶颈问题.据此,建议完善多级联动的顶层立法体系,平衡部门公众协同参与机制,锚定宏观统筹与产权边界清晰的治理导向,明晰城市更新政策边界以最大效能助力打造创新、宜居、美丽、韧性、文明、智慧城市.
Urban regeneration,as an important governance strategy in the stock-based redevelop-ment era,encounters increasing challenges from multi-domain policy synergy during its iterative upgrading process.To systematically investigate the synergistic effects of urban regeneration policies in China,this study innovatively develops a three-dimensional analytical framework encompassing spatiotemporal,content,and stakeholder dimensions.Based on the BERTopic(Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers Topic)model,a quantitative analysis is conducted on 269 urban regeneration policy documents issued by central and local governments between 2015 and 2025,focusing on four aspects:topic identification,spatiotemporal synergy,content synergy,and stakeholder synergy.The findings reveal that:(1)urban regeneration policies primarily encompass 14 topics,with their evolutionary process being divided into three stages-initiation,expansion,and all-round implementation.(2)Policy topics effectively cluster into three major categories:infrastructure regeneration,socio-economic environmental sustainability,and optimization of human settlement environment and improvement of urban functions.Nevertheless,overlaps exist within the domain of urban planning,and noticeable gaps remain in policies concerning benefit-sharing mechanisms,market incentives,and legislative frameworks.(3)Although a relatively high degree of content synergy exists between local and central government policies,bottlenecks such as dominance by single governmental departments persist.Consequently,this study recommends improving the top-level legislative framework with multi-tier coordination,balancing government-public collaboration mechanisms,orienting governance towards macro-level coordination and well-defined property right boundaries,and further clarifying policy boundaries for urban regeneration,thereby providing effective support for building innovative,livable,beautiful,resilient,civilized,and smart cities.