Isolationism or Interventionism:The Mechanism of Strategic Choices of Maritime Powers in Response to Rimland Risks
摘要
离岸平衡并非海上强国的天然首选,战略收缩有时只是权宜之计而非战略退却.从英法百年战争、英法殖民竞争、英俄中亚大博弈再到英德海上对抗,英国并没有对边缘地带保持同一性的离岸平衡姿态,反而经常深陷大陆性事务.美国经历了两次世界大战之间"踌躇的霸权"后,告别离岸平衡,冷战时期成为"受邀的霸权",后冷战时代逐渐转向"掠夺性霸权",在边缘地带不断出现基于多米诺骨牌效应反馈的动态调整.结合权力中心的地理分布与利益空间的互动性,可以耦合为对边缘地带的概念界定,提炼出一项关于海上强国如何布局边缘地带的中层理论分析框架.相比弱国而言,强国对结构性压力的反馈可能更具敏感性与主动性,这对利益遍布全球的海上强国而言尤其如此.在战略互动中,如果海上强国担忧特定边缘地带成为对手国家挑战己方的战略支点,就会偏向于干预主义,反之则向孤立主义靠拢."新门罗主义"与边缘地带干预合力塑造了美国的进攻性战略收缩态势.中国需理性研判与美国的战略缓和进程具有阶段性与可逆性,对边缘地带的大国竞争实现地缘政治风险管控,推进中美建设性战略稳定机制的空间延展.
Offshore balancing is not the first choice for maritime powers,and strategic retrenchment is just an expedient rather than a strategic retreat.Having undergone the Hundred Years'War between England and France,Anglo-French colonial competition,Anglo-Russian"Great Game"in Central Asia,and Anglo-German naval arms race,the United Kingdom did not maintain a consistent offshore balancing posture toward the rimland.Worse still,it was frequently deeply embroiled in continental affairs.The United States assumed the role of a"hesitant hegemony"during the interwar period,then it abandoned offshore balancing strategy,and its role shifted to an"invited hegemon"during the Cold War,and then to a"predatory hegemony"in the post-Cold War era,marked by continuous recalibrations in the rimland driven by feedbacks from the domino effect.Taking into consideration the interaction between geographical distribution of power centers and spheres of interest,this study reconceptualizes the rimland,and explores to gain a meso-theoretical analytical framework concerning how maritime powers make strategic arrangements in the rimland.Great powers are more sensitive and proactive toward structural pressures than weak states,and this principle better fits maritime powers with globally dispersed interests.In strategic interactions,maritime powers lean toward interventionism if they perceive a rimland region as a rival's strategic foothold for challenging them;conversely,they tend toward isolationism.The combination of the Neo-Monroe Doctrine and rimland intervention has jointly shaped the United States'posture of offensive strategic retrenchment.China should make rational judgments on her strategic ties with the United States,which are both phased and reversible,and take the initiative to manage geopolitical risks arising from great-power competition in the rimland,so as to create resilient space for the development of U.S.-China strategic stability.