军事知识服务平台
论数字时代"黑名单"制度的复合结构及适用边界
摘要 在数字时代,"黑名单"系公共管理机构对严重违反法律法规的信息主体的不良信用信息进行归集、分类和向社会公布,并在此基础上对严重失信主体的相关行为或权利实施联合惩戒的综合监管措施."黑名单"制度呈现为"严重失信+声誉制裁+信用惩戒"的复合结构,涵盖"黑名单"的列入和公布、失信联合惩戒及信用修复的全过程."黑名单"的列入和公布属于行政处罚中的"声誉罚".失信联合惩戒系对严重失信主体的第二次约束或限制,旨在预防风险,与经典行政行为中的法律制裁措施存在显著差异.嵌入于负担性行政行为中的"黑名单"联合惩戒措施贯彻的是行为责任,而具有独立属性的"黑名单"联合惩戒措施贯彻的是行为人责任.在信用修复方面,目前的"义务履行标准"已无法满足"黑名单"风险预防功能的要求,应当变更为"违法风险标准";在信用救济方面,"黑名单"的信息主体可以通过投诉、适用或参照适用行政复议、行政诉讼等方式请求认定的行为无效或撤销,并主张损害赔偿.
Abstract:
In the digital age,a"blacklist"refers to the practice by public administration agencies of col-lecting,categorizing,and publicly disclosing negative credit information about entities that have seriously violated laws and regulations,and on this basis,implementing comprehensive regulatory measures to jointly punish the relevant behaviors or rights of seriously dishonest entities.The"blacklist"system pres-ents a composite structure of"serious dishonesty,reputational sanction,and credit punishment,"covering the entire process of inclusion and disclosure in the blacklist,joint punishment for dishonesty,and credit restoration.The inclusion and disclosure of the"blacklist"fall under the"reputational penal-ty"within administrative punishment;joint punishment for dishonesty serves as the second constraint or restriction on seriously dishonest entities,aimed at risk prevention,and differs significantly from legal sanctions in classical administrative actions.The joint punishment measures embedded in burdensome ad-ministrative actions enforce behavioral responsibility,while joint punishment measures with independent attributes enforce the responsibility of the actor.Regarding credit restoration,the current"obligation per-formance standard"cannot meet the risk prevention function of the"blacklist"and should be changed to a"violation risk standard".In terms of credit relief,entities on the"blacklist"can request the invali-dation or revocation of recognized actions through complaints,or by applying for or referencing adminis-trative reconsideration,administrative litigation,and other methods,as well as claiming damages.
刊 名 当代法学 PKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 40(5)
机标分类号: D922.284 F279.23 F832.4
在线出版日期: 2026年9月21日
基金项目: 24ZDA018:国家社会科学基金,