摘要
传统法律保留只关注行政决定的内容,忽视了其行为形式.行政决定的单方性、合法性与有效性的分离、可执行性以及课予私人撤销负担等效果,决定了行政决定的行为形式会产生独立于内容的不利影响.因此,有必要将法律保留从行政决定的内容扩展至行为形式,由法律授权行政机关采用行政决定.行政的固有权、从属关系、行政程序法均不能成为行为形式的妥当基础,行为形式的授权依据应当是行政实体法规范.在判断行政机关是否有权采用行政决定时,须结合行政决定的类型与私人义务的内容,考察行政机关与私人之间法律关系的性质.行政机关有权作出行政决定并不等同于必须采用行政决定.我国行政机关经常被迫通过行政决定履行行政任务,反而不当强化了自身的优势地位.因此,我国有必要引入行政反向诉讼机制,为行政机关完成行政任务提供更多的选择手段.
The traditional doctrine of legal reservation focuses on the content of administrative acts while neglecting their modes.The unilateral nature of administrative acts,the separation of legality and validity,their enforceability,and the imposition of burdens of revocation on private parties give rise to disadvantages inherent in the mode itself,independent of its content.Therefore,it is necessary to extend the scope of legal reservation from the content of administrative acts to their modes,requiring legal au-thorization for administrative authorities to adopt administrative acts.This is known as the reservation of the administrative mode.The inherent powers of the administration,the subordinate relationship,and ad-ministrative procedural law are not appropriate foundations for the mode for administrative acts.Instead,its authorization basis should be sought within substantive administrative legal norms.When determining whether an administrative authority is entitled to adopt the mode of an administrative act,the nature of the legal relationship between the administration and the private party should be specifically examined,based on the type of administrative acts and the content of the private party's obligations.The entitlement of an administrative authority to make an administrative act does not equate to a mandatory requirement to adopt that mode.Due to the lack of administrative reverse litigation in China,administrative authorities are of-ten compelled to perform tasks through administrative acts,which paradoxically and improperly strengthens their dominant position.For this reason,we ought to introduce counter-administrative litiga-tion to furnish administrative authorities with a broader spectrum of alternative instruments for fulfilling their administrative tasks.