摘要
在我国"定性+定量"的刑事立法模式下,基本数额与加重数额均属于构成要件要素,通过依附于基础要素发挥区分不法层级的规范功能.根据主客观偏差的内容及其是否造成不法层级错位,实践中的数额认识错误可区分为事实与评价错位型错误和跨越法定刑幅度型错误,并依次展开判断.对于前者,应依据行为人标准说,将数额要素区分为基础性事实、评价性事实与规范评价.如果行为人针对"较大数额的财物"或"(特别)巨大数额的财物"等评价性事实产生错误认识,应视为事实认识错误,可以阻却基本构成要件故意或加重构成要件故意.对于后者,由于法定刑升格条件中的加重数额虽未改变行为类型,却实质提升了违法程度,因而依托定量要素划分不法层级,并对应梯度法定刑的基本构成与加重构成,在性质上已趋于相对独立的罪刑单位.故对于跨越不同法定刑幅度的数额认识错误,宜认定为抽象的事实认识错误,并依据法定符合说予以处理.
Under China's criminal legislative model,which combines qualitative definitions of offenses with quantitative thresholds,both basic and aggravated monetary thresholds constitute elements of the offense.By attaching to underlying elements such as conduct,the object of the offense,or the resulting harm,these quantitative elements perform the constitutive function of differentiating degrees of criminal wrongfulness.Depending on the object of the discrepancy between the actor's perception and the objective circumstances,and on whether that discrepancy results in a mismatch between different levels of wrong-fulness,mistakes as to monetary amounts in judicial practice may be classified into two categories:mis-takes involving a mismatch between factual perception and normative evaluation,and mistakes that cross statutory penalty ranges,which should be analyzed in that order.With respect to the first category,an actor-oriented standard should be adopted,under which quantitative elements are divided into basic facts,evaluative facts,and normative evaluations.Where an actor is mistaken as to the evaluative facts underlying the characterization of property as being of a"relatively large","huge"or"especially huge"amount,the mistake should be treated as a mistake of fact.It may therefore negate the intent required for either the basic offense or the aggravated offense.With respect to the second category,although the aggra-vated monetary threshold as a condition for an enhanced statutory penalty does not alter the underlying type of conduct,it substantially increases the degree of wrongfulness.Accordingly,the basic offense and the aggravated offense,which distinguish levels of wrongfulness by reference to quantitative elements and correspond to different graduated statutory penalty ranges,have substantively become relatively independent units of offense and punishment.A mistake as to amount that crosses different statutory penalty ranges should therefore be characterized as an abstract mistake of fact and resolved in accordance with the doctrine of statutory correspondence.