军事知识服务平台
数字时代背景下《民法典》格式条款订入规则研究
摘要 在数字时代,《民法典》格式条款订入规则面临缔约程序操控、市场竞争失灵、合同关系预期削弱、合同更新频繁、监管手段及成本受限等现实挑战.相应地,其适用对象不应仅限于因违反法律规定而具有剥夺或限制效果的条款.在认定标准上,应聚焦如何矫正合同双方在数字时代日益加剧的信息不对称和缔约地位失衡.在提示说明义务对象的认定上,法律适用应当在遵循合意认定的体系定位和信息供给的功能属性之基础上,通过调整认定方法应对数字时代的现实挑战.《民法典》第 496 条第 2 款及相关司法解释中"有重大利害关系"与"异常"的表述,应被视为提示说明义务适用对象的构成要件.其中,"异常"在数字时代背景下的认定,应当取决于在外观、表述和缔约程序层面,相对方是否享有获取、注意、阅读、理解和存储格式条款的充足机会;"有重大利害关系"则用以检验保护相对方的必要性.应当尽可能降低"有重大利害关系"的认定标准,使得任何有可能不利于相对方的条款都需进行"异常"与否的判断,以期在新的时代背景下实现以格式条款订入规则保障合同透明度、矫正缔约地位失衡的现实目标.
Abstract:
In the digital era,the incorporation rules for standard terms under the Civil Code face practical challenges,including the manipulation of contracting procedures,market failure,weakened expectations in contractual relationships,frequent contract renewals,and constraints on regulatory measures and costs.Accordingly,the application targets of these rules-namely,the terms subject to the duty to draw attention to and explain-should not be limited to those that have a depriving or restricting effect due to le-gal violations.Instead,the identification criteria should focus on how to rectify the increasingly aggravated information asymmetry and imbalance in contracting status between the parties in the digital age.In identifying the targets of the duty to draw attention to and explain,and on the basis of adhering to the systematic positioning of consensus determination and the functional attribute of information supply,legal application should adjust the identification methods to cope with the practical challenges of the digit-al era.The expressions"of significant interest"and"abnormal"in Article 496,Paragraph 2 of the Civil Code and its judicial interpretations should be regarded as the constitutive requirements for the targets of the duty to draw attention to and explain.Specifically,the identification standard for"abnormal"in the digital context should be whether the counterparty objectively enjoys sufficient opportunities to obtain,no-tice,read,understand,and store the standard clauses in terms of appearance,expression,and contrac-ting procedures;whereas"of significant interest"is used to test the necessity of protecting the counterp-arty.The identification standard for"of significant interest"should be lowered as much as possible,so that any term potentially disadvantageous to the counterparty must be judged as to whether it is"abnormal."This approach aims to realize the practical goal of the incorporation rules for standard terms in the new era:ensuring contract transparency and constraining excessively dominant contracting positions to a certain extent.
刊 名 当代法学 PKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 40(5)
机标分类号: D922.284 F832.51 F279.246
在线出版日期: 2026年9月21日
基金项目: 25YC820012:教育部人文社会科学研究项目,