军事知识服务平台
优势盈亏、秩序内外与美国的技术竞争策略选择
Advantage Profit-and-Loss,Order Inside-and-Outside and U.S.Strategic Choices in Technological Competition
摘要 二战结束以来,美国的国际技术竞争实践呈现市场范式与战略范式交替主导的周期性特征,竞争策略的运用也存在显著的时空差异.在中美技术竞争愈演愈烈的背景下,这一现象的生成机制已成为亟待讨论的理论问题.对此,既有的威胁认知、技术挑战和技术周期等分析视角尚无法给出系统性解释.以霸权国护持技术权力为逻辑起点,文章聚焦技术优势条件和国际秩序环境两个变量,构建了美国技术竞争的策略选择理论:技术优势的充分程度影响美国干预现状的动机,驱动其在市场范式与战略范式间转换;秩序环境则框定竞争行为的边界,使干预强度在克制与激进间分化.二者的交互作用衍生出自由放任、单向遏制、有限干预和全面竞胜四种策略类型.历史案例表明,美苏高科技竞争(1945~1969)与美日半导体竞争(20世纪60~90年代)均依理论预期,分别呈现由单向遏制到全面竞胜和由自由放任到有限干预的转变.该理论亦为理解2018年以来的中美技术竞争提供了分析思路.研究揭示了美国技术竞争策略的复杂机制,为应对长期技术竞争提供政策启示.
Abstract:
Since the end of World War Ⅱ,U.S.practices in international technological competition have exhibited cyclical characteristics dominated alternately by the market-oriented paradigm and the strategy-oriented paradigm,with significant temporal and spatial variations in the application of competition strategies.Against the backdrop of intensifying U.S.China technological competition,the mechanisms underlying this phenomenon have become a theoretical issue requiring urgent discussion.Existing analytical perspectives,including threat perception,technological challenges,and technology cycles,fail to offer a systematic explanation.Taking the hegemon maintenance of technological power as the logical starting point,this article focuses on two variables-conditions of technological advantage and the international order environment-to construct a theory of U.S.technological competition strategy selection:The sufficiency of technological advantage influences U.S.motivation to intervene in the status quo,driving shifts between market-oriented and strategy-oriented paradigms;the international order environment,in turn,delineates the boundaries of competitive behavior,causing the intensity of intervention to differentiate between restraint and radicalness.The interaction of these two variables generates four strategic types:laissez-faire,unilateral containment,limited intervention,and comprehensive competitive ascendancy.Historical cases demonstrate that both U.S.-Soviet high-tech competition(1945-1969)and U.S.-Japan semiconductor competition(1960s-1990s)align with theoretical expectations,showing transitions from unilateral containment to comprehensive competitive ascendancy,and from laissez-faire to limited intervention,respectively.The theory also provides an analytical framework for understanding U.S.-China technological competition since 2018.The study reveals the complex mechanisms behind U.S.technological competition strategies,offering policy insights for addressing long-term technological competition.
刊 名 当代亚太 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2025, (6)
机标分类号: F246 D815 F127
在线出版日期: 2026年1月22日