军事知识服务平台
污染环境罪的累积犯法理再诠释
摘要 在构建中国刑法学自主知识体系的语境下,污染环境罪的累积犯法理诠释需要融入领域法论和功能主义方法论,以最大限度实现污染环境罪解释结论的整全有效性.作为污染环境罪的行为对象的污染物,可以分为"危险有毒物质"与"有害物质"两种规范类型,相应地,将作为累积犯的污染环境罪区分为作为"强累积犯"的"危险有毒物质"型污染环境罪、作为"弱累积犯"的"有害物质"型污染环境罪两种规范类型,在同立法规定和司法解释保持对应协调的同时,有利于类型化解决污染环境罪的行为不法和责任判断问题."增强意识"型放任责任理论可以作为环境资源领域刑法论和累积犯论的重要法理,将那些明显违背"增强"防止污染环境意识要求且明显不属于正常经营活动的"轻信能够避免的态度",实质地解释为"开放容忍的态度"即放任态度,从而使污染环境罪的放任责任范围适当宽于其他普通犯罪放任责任范围.结合当前我国刑法和司法解释的规定,前端原材料的提供者、委托处置污染物的委托者、提供租赁驾乘服务的出租人与驾乘人等三种主体的"增强意识"型放任责任判断,尚存较为突出的解释论争议,亟需更加深刻的累积犯法理研究和有效阐释.
Abstract:
Against the backdrop of developing an autonomous knowledge system of Chinese criminal law,the jurisprudential interpretation of the crime of environmental pollution must inte-grate domain-specific legal theory and functionalist methodology to maximise the integrity and effectiveness of interpretive outcomes.Pollutants,as the objects of conduct in the crime of envi-ronmental pollution,can be categorized into two normative types:"hazardous and toxic sub-stances"and"harmful substances."Correspondingly,the crime of environmental pollution as a cumulative offense can be distinguished into two normative categories:the"hazardous and toxic substances"type,constituting a"strong cumulative offense",and the"harmful substances"type,constituting a"weak cumulative offense."This typology,while maintaining correspondence and coherence with legislative provisions and judicial interpretations,facilitates the categorical resolu-tion of issues pertaining to the wrongfulness of the conduct and the assessment of culpability in environmental pollution crimes.The"Enhanced Awareness"model of dolus eventualis liability can serve as a significant jurisprudential basis for criminal law theory and cumulative offense theory in the domain of environmental and resource law.It substantively interprets an attitude of"rash confidence that pollution can be avoided"which patently violates the requirement to"en-hance"awareness for preventing environmental pollution and clearly falls outside legitimate ordi-nary business activities,as an attitude of"open tolerance,"that is,dolus eventualis.Thereby,the scope of reckless liability for the crime of environmental pollution is appropriately broader than that for other ordinary crimes.An examination of current Chinese criminal law and judicial inter-pretations reveals that prominent interpretative controversies persist regarding the assessment of"Enhanced Awareness"dolus eventualis for three types of actors:providers of upstream raw ma-terials,principals who commission others to dispose of pollutants,and lessors,drivers as well as occupants involved in leased transportation services.This underscores an urgent need for more profound research on the jurisprudence of cumulative offenses and effective elaboration.