军事知识服务平台
关系刑法学视域下犯罪论体系重构
摘要 在关系刑法学视域下,犯罪被定义为加害者和受害者之间严重对立的交互关系.其中加害者的规范违反行为是犯罪关系的"正题",受害者的法益损害后果是犯罪关系的"反题","加害—受害"交互过程的内部因果性和外部社会危害性是犯罪关系的"合题",三者遵循正反合的辩证逻辑.在新的范式下,刑法学的学派之争将因对犯罪认识的变革而走向整合,也为犯罪论体系的重构提供了契机.关系刑法学的犯罪论体系呈现三维特征,需要依次审查加害维度的规范违反性、受害维度的法益侵害性、交互维度的社会危害性,最终作出罪与非罪的结论.该体系突破了犯罪人中心观的单一性视角,具有视域升维、学说融合特征,可以有效解决犯罪情节评价、行为人与被害人责任划分等实务难题.
Abstract:
From the perspective of relational criminal law,crime is defined as a seriously antagonistic interactive relationship between the perpetrator and the victim.The perpetrator's norm-violating behavior constitutes the"thesis"of the criminal relationship,while the victim's resultant harm to legal interests the harmful result inflicted on the victim's legally protected in-terests represents the"antithesis."The"synthesis"emerges from the internal causality and exter-nal social harmfulness of the perpetrator-victim interaction process.These three components ad-here to the dialectical logic of thesis,antithesis,and synthesis.This new paradigm offers a trans-formative understanding of the nature of crime,potentially reconciling longstanding debates a-mong schools of criminal law thought.Moreover,it presents an opportunity to reconstruct the criminal theory system.The crime theory system of relational criminal law presents three-dimen-sional characteristics,requiring sequential examination of the normative violation in the perpetra-tor dimension,the infringement of legal interests in the victim dimension,and the socialharmful-ness in the interaction dimension,ultimately reaching a conclusion of whether an act constitutes a crime or not.This system breaks through the one-dimensional perspective of offender-centered criminal theory and is characterized by an elevated analytical horizon and the integration of com-peting doctrines.It can effectively address practical difficulties such as the evaluation of the cir-cumstances of crime and the allocation of responsibility between the actor and the victim.
刊 名 东方法学 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (2)
分类号: DF61
机标分类号: D924 F812.42 F230
在线出版日期: 2026年6月3日
基金项目: 23JJD820002:教育部人文社会科学研究项目GJ2023C16:最高人民检察院检察理论项目,