军事知识服务平台
论行政规划的强制性
摘要 强制性是审视行政规划样态的重要维度,在法治语境下,规划的强制性需与法律实现关联而呈现差异化特征.我国行政规划的强制性经历了从"天然属性"到"外部属性"的转变,即从行政上、事实上的强制性转向法律上、规范上的强制性.学界对此形成了"肯定说""否定说""情况说"等观点,其中"情况说"立足于现代法治语境,更符合规划的制度实践与发展方向.在内在机理上,国家权力的正当行使、公共利益优位与行政效能等因素共同构成了规划强制性的正当性与必要性基础.在表达方式上,法律规定通过法律效力、程序保障、后果追究等具体规范条款,以多元方式塑造了行政规划的强制性.在规制路径上,为确保强制性不被滥用,须在实体上要求规划恪守"法律保留",确保规划内容符合上位规划要求和公共利益目的,并在稳定性与情势变更间探索创新机制;在程序上重点强化公众参与、专家咨询的可操作性与实效性,以"过程正义"保障"结果正义";在救济上提供行政复议、行政诉讼和国家赔偿等多元途径,通过统一定位强调行政的内部控制,并建立多元灵活的行政补偿制度,以平衡公共利益与个人权益.
Abstract:
Compulsoriness is an important dimension for evaluating the types of administra-tive planning.In the context of the rule of law,the compulsoriness of planning must be linked to the realization of law and therefore exhibits differentiated features.In China,the compulsoriness of administrative planning has undergone a shift from an"inherent attribute"to an"external at-tribute,"that is,from administrative and de facto coercion to legal and normative compulsoriness.Scholarly opinion has accordingly developed into the affirmative view,the negative view,and the differential view,of which the differential view,grounded in the modern rule-of-law order,better accords with the institutional practice and developmental direction of administrative planning.In terms of the internal mechanism,legitimate exercise,the priority of public interests,and adminis-trative efficiency,among other factors,jointly support the legitimacy and necessity of administra-tive planning's compulsoriness.In terms of expression,legal provisions have shaped the compul-soriness of administrative planning through various expression methods such as legal effect,pro-cedural guarantees,and consequence accountability.In terms of regulatory paths,to ensure that compulsoriness is not abused,in substance,it is necessary to constrain planning to abide by"le-gal reservation",and its content should conform to the superior planning and public interest goals as well as should explore innovative mechanisms for reconciling planning stability with changed circumstances.In procedures,it focuses on strengthening the operability and effectiveness of public participation and expert consultation so that"procedural justice"may secure"substantive justice".In remedies,it provides multiple channels such as administrative reconsideration,ad-ministrative litigation and state compensation.A coherent characterization of these remedies should underscore the importance of internal administrative control and establishes diverse and flexible administrative compensation system to balance public interests and individual rights.
刊 名 东方法学 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (2)
分类号: DF3
机标分类号: D922.1 F275 D630.1
在线出版日期: 2026年6月3日
基金项目: 25CFX128:国家社会科学基金,