Effects of vegetation and terraces on the watershed runoff-sediment relationship on the Chinese Loess Plateau
摘要
植被梯田等坡面水保措施已显著改变了黄土区景观.针对坡面水保措施是否改变流域水沙关系这一问题,选择坝库修建较少的祖厉河流域(黄丘五区)、天水站(黄丘三区)和西峰站(黄土塬区)进行了研究,研究时段从20世纪50年代至今.在天水站和西峰站,尽管流域治理减沙率高达60%左右,但仍重现了前期研究在晋西离石站(黄丘一区)的结果,即水沙关系不变、含沙量不变、减水率和减沙率接近.在祖厉河,流域治理减沙率高达82%,但60余年来日尺度水沙关系保持不变,洪水期含沙量始终为645±5%kg/m3.与天水站和西峰站不同,祖厉河的年水沙关系发生了变化,主要是由于治理后流量减幅太大,以至于小流量且低含沙量的组分显著增加.在黄土区,流量低于某一阈值后含沙量才衰减,因此只有当流域治理达到相当程度、流量减至该阈值以下时,才会诱发含沙量的降低,使得减沙效率激增,这为黄河产沙锐减提供了新的解释.研究结果表明,尽管黄土区植被和梯田建设导致"山川巨变",但日或事件尺度的流域水沙关系保持不变.这意味着对以坡面治理为主的流域,洪水期或极端降雨下仍会出现与治理前相同的高含沙量,减沙仅通过减洪实现,因此减沙率可直接用减洪率估计,这对解决植被梯田减沙效益估算这一难题具有重要意义.
Slope soil and water conservation(SWC)measures,mainly including vegetation and terraces,have significantly changed the landscape of the Loess Plateau.To address the key question of whether these slope measures alter the basin-wide runoff-sediment relationship,this study selected three study areas with minimal reservoir construction:the Zuli River Basin(Loess Hilly-Gully Region V),Tianshui Station(Loess Hilly-Gully Region Ⅲ),and Xifeng Sta-tion(Loess Tableland Region),covering a research period from the 1950s to the present.At Tianshui and Xifeng stations,despite a substantial sediment reduction rate of approximately 60%due to basin management,the results from previous studies at Lishi Station in western Shanxi(Loess Hilly-Gully Region I)were replicated:the runoff-sediment relationship and sedi-ment concentration remained unchanged,with sediment reduction rates closely matching runoff reduction rates.In the Zuli River Basin,the sediment reduction rate reached as high as 82%,yet the daily-scale runoff-sediment relationship has remained stable over the past six decades,with flood-season sediment concentration consistently around 640 kg/m3.Unlike Tianshui and Xi-feng stations,the annual runoff-sediment relationship in this basin has changed,primarily be-cause basin management has reduced runoff so much that large floods have become small,low sediment events.On the Loess Plateau,sediment concentration only decreases when runoff falls below a specific threshold.Thus,when runoff is reduced below this threshold,sediment concentration decreases synchronously,leading to a sharp increase in sediment reduction effi-ciency—providing a new explanation for the drastic reduction in sediment yield of the Yellow River.The results indicate that despite the drastic landscape changes caused by vegetation resto-ration and terrace construction in the Loess Plateau,the daily or event-scale runoff-sediment re-lationship remains unchanged.This implies that in basins dominated by SWC measures,high sediment concentrations comparable to those before management may still occur during flood seasons or extreme rainfall events.Therefore,the sediment reduction rate of a flood event can be directly estimated using the runoff reduction rate,which is of great significance for solving the long-standing challenge of quantifying the sediment reduction benefits of vegetation and ter-race measures.