军事知识服务平台
论司法政策的扩权现象及其治理思路
摘要 司法机关借由司法政策将司法权延伸至"规则创制"领域,使指导性案例、会议纪要、意见、通知等司法政策载体形式的规范性文件遭受到权力僭越的指责.就司法政策扩权的制度逻辑而言,其反映了司法机关基于统一法律适用的职责,为应对疑难问题进行的制度适应与创新.就司法政策扩权的历史逻辑而言,该现象的产生与政策文本在不同历史阶段的"混同"应用及国家在不同时期的中心任务和治理需求相关.就司法政策扩权的政治逻辑而言,扩权现象本质上是权力结构、社会需求与司法功能博弈的结果.需理性看待司法政策扩权现象,反思不同载体形式司法政策的功能定位,对之进行科学区分,并强化司法政策制定的程序约束,以降低扩权风险.
Abstract:
Judicial organs extend judicial authority to the domain of norm creation via judicial policies.Accordingly,judicial policy carriers including guiding cases,meeting minutes,judicial opinions and circulars are suspected of ultra vires exercise of public power by virtue of judicial status.Institutionally,the expansion of judicial policies represents institutional adjustment and innovation adopted by judicial authorities to tackle difficult judicial issues,in accordance with their statutory duty to guarantee uniform application of laws.Historically,such phenomenon arises from the generalized application of policy documents across historical periods,as well as national central tasks and governance requirements in different eras.Politically,power expansion essentially results from the interaction of national power structure,social governance demands and judicial functions.It is essential to treat judicial policy expansion rationally,distinguish functional positioning of diversified judicial policies,and strengthen procedural constraints over policy formulation,so as to mitigate risks of excessive judicial power.
刊 名 法学 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 534(5)
机标分类号: D916 U617 D630.9
在线出版日期: 2026年6月25日