军事知识服务平台
同时履行抗辩权的牵连性理论重构
摘要 我国民法学界通说认为,同时履行抗辩权的牵连性源于双务合同中两项债务之间的对价关系,其本质在于原因理论中当事人"负担债务"的意思内容,然而这一理解难以实现同时履行抗辩权所追求的广泛公平理念,亦仅为德国法中给付抗辩权特殊体系下的理论产物.从制度史考察,履行上的牵连性在思想、格言、定式、范围及理念上均有更为广义的注解,应以均衡牵连关系理论对我国法上同时履行抗辩权的牵连性基础予以重构.均衡牵连关系理论旨在表明两项对立性债务须起源于同一法律关系,且一方不履行债务而强制对方履行对立性债务会破坏法律关系的均衡时,债务间的牵连关系始得成立.对均衡的判断应综合考量履行安排、交易目的、给付间价值及合理妥当等要素并据此作出规范性评价.均衡牵连关系理论在实现进路上契合我国法"合同构成"的整体分析框架,但在性质与功能上区别于德国法上"债权性留置权"、我国法上物权性留置权、关联债务抵销制度中的牵连性构造.该理论不仅可兼容我国现有规范体系,也可回应包括双务合同中"非主要债务"、合同关系外债务以及继续性合同、合同联立等新型交易形态中的债务在内的各类履行抗辩难题,展现出广泛的解释力与实践价值.
Abstract:
The prevailing view in Chinese civil law academia grounds the connectivity of the simultaneous performance defense in reciprocal connectivity within bilateral contract,rooted in the parties'intent to"assume obligations"under the causa doctrine.However,this understanding inadequately accommodates the broader fairness underlying the simultaneous performance defense,as it is merely a theoretical product of the unique framework of performance defenses in German law.Historically,the connectivity of performance has been interpreted more broadly in terms of ideology,maxim,formulation,scope and philosophy.Therefore,the connectivity basis for the simultaneous performance defense in Chinese law should be reconstructed based on the theory of balanced connectivity.This theory posits that two opposing obligations should arise from the same legal relationship,and the connectivity exists only when one party's failure to perform forces the other to fulfill its opposing obligation,thereby disrupting the equilibrium of the legal relationship.The assessment of this equilibrium should comprehensively consider factors such as the performance arrangement,transactional purpose,value of performances,and overall reasonableness.In method,the theory aligns with the holistic"contractual constitution"approach in Chinese law.However,in its nature and function,it differs from the German"obligational retention right"and from Chinese rules on retention and the set-off concerning related obligations.The theory not only finds interpretive support within China's existing normative system but also addresses challenges in applying the defense to non-primary obligations,extra-contractual obligations,ongoing contracts,and interconnected contracts,demonstrating considerable explanatory power and practical value.
刊 名 法学 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 534(5)
机标分类号: D923.6 B84-065 O317.2
在线出版日期: 2026年6月25日
基金项目: 21BFX076:国家社会科学基金,