摘要
国际投资争端中涉及第三方利益的情形愈发常见,但第三方在争端中的法律地位仍存在较大争议,特别是"不可或缺第三方"能否存在于国际投资争端之中,迄今尚无明确答案.通过梳理不可或缺第三方理论的内涵并分析相关典型案例,可以发现该理论以可受理性为基础,其适用逻辑能够延伸至国际投资争端领域.根据部分投资争端案例所揭示的识别标准,在投资位于争议领土或水域、投资标的所有权不确定,以及投资活动产生负外部性等典型场景中,均可能存在不可或缺第三方.为更有效地解决国际投资争端,争端当事方及潜在第三方应妥善运用该理论维护自身权益,国际社会应推动相关规则的澄清与完善,以促进国际投资法的规范、有序与可预期发展.
Situations in which third-party interests are implicated in international investment disputes have become increasingly common,yet the legal status of third parties within such disputes remains deeply contested.In particular,no clear answer has yet emerged as to whether an"indispensable third party"may exist in the context of international investment dispute settlement.By examining the conceptual foundations of the indispensable third party doctrine and analysing the relevant leading cases,this article argues that the doctrine is grounded in admissibility and that its underlying logic is capable of extending to the field of international investment disputes.Drawing on the criteria for identification reflected in certain investment cases,the article further contends that indispensable third parties may arise in several typical scenarios,including disputes involving investments located in disputed territory or maritime areas,investments whose ownership is uncertain,and investments that generate negative externalities.In order to facilitate the more effective resolution of international investment disputes,both disputing parties and potential third parties should make appropriate use of this doctrine to safeguard their respective rights and interests.At the same time,the international community should promote the clarification and refinement of the relevant rules so as to foster a more coherent,orderly,and predictable development of international investment law.