军事知识服务平台
"足以排除强制执行的民事权益"的类型建构及方法
The Typological Construction and Methodology of'Civil Rights and Interests Sufficient to Exclude Compulsory Enforcement'
摘要 足以排除强制执行的民事权益的性质为阻却被执行财产转让的干预权,也是对民事权利的否定性防御权.它用于确定被执行人的责任财产范围,以决定被执行人对财产的权利或权利外观能否对抗案外人.其类型建构首先应运用法教义学,案外人的所有权、其他具有确定归属功能的财产权益等,除善意取得情形外,均可阻却强制执行;若强制执行导致地役权、担保物权、所有权担保的权能或效力贬损时,案外人也可阻却强制执行.司法解释有关不动产买受人的债权在特定情形阻却强制执行的基础是利益衡量,其出发点是权衡生计保障和经济利益,不宜诉诸期待权或中间型权利.对司法解释未涉及的借名情形出资人的权益能否阻却强制执行,因缺乏固定要件,且释义逻辑难以穿透,利益衡量可能导致价值专断,此时可通过动态体系判定.通过运用权益、意志、控制、信赖和关系五个原理性要素,辅之以更为具体的因素,可以合理确定固定要件,也可以反思固定要件的合理性.干预权类型建构涉及如何明确不确定概念的三种民法方法,也可作为统一民事法学建构的方法论样本.
Abstract:
The nature of a civil interest sufficient to preclude compulsory execution lies in a right of intervention that precludes the transfer of property subject to execution,as well as a right of negative defense against civil rights.It serves to delimit the scope of the judgment debtor's property liable for execution,thereby determining whether the debtor's title to the property,or the appearance of such title,may be asserted against a third party.Its typological construction should first be undertaken by means of legal dogmatics.A third party's ownership and other property interests with the function of determining attribution may all preclude compulsory execution,save for cases of bona fide acquisition;if compulsory execution impairs the powers or efficacy of easements,security interests,or title-security rights,the third party may also preclude compulsory execution.The recognition by judicial interpretations that a real estate purchaser's claim may preclude compulsory execution under specific circumstances is grounded in interest balancing.Its point of departure is the weighing of livelihood protection against economic interests,and it should not resort to expectancy rights or intermediate-type rights.For nominee arrangements not addressed by judicial interpretations,whether the actual contributor's interests can preclude compulsory execution may,in such cases,be determined through a dynamic system,given the absence of fixed constituent elements,the difficulty of extending interpretive logic by analogy,and the risk that interest balancing may lead to arbitrary value judgments.By deploying five principled elements—interests,will,control,reliance,and relationship—supplemented by more specific factors,fixed constituent elements may be reasonably determined,and their reasonableness may likewise be reconsidered.The typological construction of the right of intervention involves three civil law approaches to clarifying indeterminate concepts,and may also serve as a methodological exemplar for the unified construction of civil law doctrine.
刊 名 法治研究 PKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 167(5)
机标分类号: D923.2 TP182 F812.42
在线出版日期: 2026年11月6日
基金项目: DF2023YS32:中国社会科学院学科建设登峰战略资助计划项目,