论数据法益刑法保护的累积犯规制模式
On the Cumulative Offense Regulatory Model for the Criminal Protection of Data Legal Interests
摘要
数据法益的刑法保护存在对"海量微损"型数据法益侵害行为的规制阙如,而理解数据法益的内涵是实现其全面保护的前提.鉴于数据的价值性、技术性与关联性的固有属性,应当形成由独立的数据安全法益与数据所关联的个体法益相结合的复合法益构造.现有的财产法益观、类型化法益观和传统双层法益观等保护方案,均难以全面地评价累积性侵害对数据法益带来的系统性风险.因此,有必要引入累积犯规制模式.该模式在遵循比例原则限定处罚范围的前提下,为"海量微损"型法益侵害行为构建由事实归因、整体责任归属与个别化责任归属组成的三阶段审查标准.进而可以在流量劫持、数据爬取、公共数据篡改以及技术扩散型数据累积侵害等典型场景中,实现精准的刑法规制.
The criminal law protection of legal interests in data faces a regulatory gap in addressing infringement of legal interests in data of the'mass minor harm'type.A clear understanding of the connotation of legal interests in data is the prerequisite for realizing their comprehensive protection.Given the inherent attributes of legal interests in data,namely value,technicality and relevance,a compound structure of legal interests shall be established,which combines independent legal interests in data security and individual legal interests associated with the data.Existing protection frameworks,including the theory of property legal interests,the theory of typed legal interests and the traditional dual-layer theory of legal interests,all fail to fully assess the systemic risks brought by cumulative infringement.It is therefore necessary to introduce the regulatory model of cumulative offense.Subject to the principle of proportionality to define the scope of punishment,this model establishes a three-stage review standard for infringement of legal interests of the'mass minor harm'type,which consists of factual attribution,holistic attribution of liability and individualized attribution of liability.This model further enables precise criminal law regulation in typical scenarios,including traffic hijacking,data scraping,tampering with public data,and technology-diffused cumulative infringement of data.
年,卷(期):
2026, 167(5)
机标分类号:
D924.3
F832.33
F279.246
在线出版日期:
2026年11月6日
基金项目:
KJQN202600310:重庆市教委科技青年项目,