军事知识服务平台
医疗脑机接口产品致害风险的刑法规制
Criminal Regulation of Harm Risks Posed by Medical Brain-Computer Interface Products
摘要 医疗脑机接口产品致害风险具有结构复杂性、责任主体多元性、损害后果不可逆性等特征.对医疗脑机接口产品致害行为的刑事不法判断与归责存在难题.医疗脑机接口产品安全标准是识别行为人注意义务、判断业务过失的重要参考依据.刑法应根据医疗脑机接口产品技术特性与风险特征,明确医疗脑机接口产品容许风险的边界,搭建注意义务框架.由研发者把控源头性技术安全,生产者保障产品质量安全,运营者防范医疗神经数据安全风险,医疗机构规范临床操作应用,销售者保证合规经营与风险告知,患者等消费者确保合规使用与配合诊疗活动.在刑法因果关系认定中,需要依据患者特殊体质、不当行为、第三方干预等介入因素的异常性程度、对损害结果是否具有支配性影响,及其是否属于行为人的风险管辖范围等情况进行判断.对医疗脑机接口产品共同致害行为的刑事责任认定,须区分故意和过失情形.共同故意致害行为构成共同犯罪,在医疗脑机接口产品"研发—生产—应用"链条式产业协作场景下,应重点考察行为人是否存在默示合意与协作行为;对于共同过失致害行为,应综合分析参与者的过失程度、预见可能性及对损害结果的影响力度等因素,分别确定其刑事责任.
Abstract:
The harm risks posed by medical brain-computer interface products are characterized by structural complexity,diverse liability subjects,and irreversible consequences of harm.Determining criminal unlawfulness and attributing responsibility for harmful conduct arising from medical brain-computer interface products presents substantial difficulties.Safety standards for medical brain-computer interface products serve as an important reference for identifying the duty of care and assessing professional negligence.In light of the technological and risk attributes of medical brain-computer interface products,criminal law ought to delineate the limits of permitted risks and construct a duty of care framework.Researchers should control fundamental technological safety,manufacturers should ensure product quality,operators should prevent risks to medical neural data security,medical institutions should standardize clinical practices,sellers should guarantee compliance and risk disclosure,while patients and consumers should ensure proper use and cooperation in treatment activities.For the determination of causation in criminal law,it is necessary to assess factors such as the patient's special constitution,improper conduct,or third-party intervention,considering the abnormality of these factors,whether they exert a dominant influence on the harmful outcome,and whether they fall within the risk governance scope of the actor.The determination of criminal liability for joint harmful conduct involving medical brain-computer interface products requires distinguishing between intentional and negligent acts.Joint intentional harmful conduct constitutes joint crime;within the'research-production-application'chain of medical brain-computer interface industry collaboration,emphasis should be placed on examining whether implicit agreement and cooperative actions exist among the actors.For joint negligent harmful conduct,participants'degrees of negligence,foreseeability,and influence on the harmful outcome should be comprehensively analyzed to determine their respective criminal liabilities.
刊 名 法治研究 PKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 167(5)
机标分类号: D924 F426.61 TP393.4
在线出版日期: 2026年11月6日