摘要
司法三段论的基本模式是将法律规范作为大前提,将案件事实作为小前提,推出判决结论.其中,规定"行为构成要件"和"法律后果",并以"若(如果)……则(那么)……"的语句结构表达的裁判规范[∀x(Tx→ORx)]构成推理的大前提,将实际发生的案件原初事实集[S(S1,S2,S3,……Sn)]与裁判规范规定的"行为构成要件"(T)之间进行逻辑"涵摄"联结,得出Ta(Sa,且Sa∈Tx)作为推理的小前提,再根据此小前提以及裁判规范规定的大前提,推导出ORa(Ta→ORx)的逻辑(裁判)结论.但在司法实践中,司法三段论推理经常遭遇所谓"疑难案件"之识别与判断难题的困扰,因而在S和T之间存在"涵摄不能"情形,需要通过"解释学循环"在事实与规范之间找到它们联结的逻辑点(或涵摄的可能性条件),分层和分类处理其中的难题.
The basic mode of judicial syllogism involves taking legal norms as the major premise,the facts of the case as the minor premise,and deriving the judgment as the conclusion.Among these,the adjudicative norm,which prescribes the"constituent elements of conduct"and the"legal consequences",and is expressed in the sentence structure of"if...then...",constitutes the major premise of the reasoning.The original set of facts of the actual case[S(S1,S2,S3......Sn)]is logically"subsumed"under the"constituent elements of conduct"(T)stipulated by the adjudicative norm,resul-ting in(,and)as the minor premise of the reasoning.Based on this minor premise and the major premise stipulated by the adjudicative norm,the logical(adjudicative)conclusion(ORa(Ta→ORx))is derived.However,in judicial prac-tice,judicial syllogistic reasoning often encounters the dilemma of identifying and judging so-called"difficult cases."Consequently,in situations where"subsumption is impossible"between S and T,it is necessary to find the logical point of connection(or the condition for the possibility of subsumption)between fact and norm through the"hermeneutic circle,"addressing the difficulties in a layered and categorized manner.