摘要
最高人民法院以主观过错为说理工具改判"盈海公司案"并不妥当.该案行为人属于明知故犯,具有主观过错,但该案所处的特殊情形决定了不能对其提出守法的意志期待.该案中所运用的理论工具可能是期待可能性.行政处罚具有政策性倾向、开放性结构和责任主义立场,期待可能性在行政处罚中的作用更加凸显.但是,由于风险社会中倾斜保护公共利益的治理需求,期待可能性必须被限制适用,不宜被列入公报案例全面推广.一方面,期待可能性应满足严苛的启动条件,以"行为人标准"谨慎衡量"是否存在异常情形"和"是否没有选择他行为的可能性"为前提;另一方面,为了避免破坏法的安定性,其适用必须于法有据,不宜作为超法规责任阻却事由,也不宜写入《行政处罚法》.
It is inappropriate for the Supreme People's Court to take subjective fault as the reasoning tool to reverse the"Yinghai Company Case".The actor in this case knowingly violated the law and bore subjective fault,yet the special cir-cumstances in which he was situated determined that he could not be expected to have the will to abide by the law.The the-oretical tool applied in this case is more likely to be anticipated possibility.Given that administrative penalty features a pol-icy-oriented tendency,open structure,and the doctrine of culpability,the role of anticipated possibility in administrative penalty becomes more prominent.However,due to the governance demand of tilted protection of public interests in a risk society,anticipated possibility must be restrictively applied and should not be comprehensively promoted by being included in gazette cases.On the one hand,anticipated possibility should meet stringent initiation conditions,prudently assessing"whether there are abnormal circumstances"and"whether there is no possibility of choosing alternative conduct"based on the"actor standard".On the other hand,in order to avoid undermining legal stability,its application must have a legal ba-sis;it should neither be regarded as an extra-legal ground for excluding liability,nor should it be incorporated into the Administrative Penalty Law.