摘要
《公司法》第23条尚未系统确认逆向揭纱规则,仅在第2款的公司集团整体揭纱规则中蕴含了逆向揭纱元素.基于诚实信用、公平与禁止权利滥用等原则,应确认逆向揭纱规则的正当性,但要保持逆向揭纱规则的高度谦抑性.鉴于《企业改制司法解释》第7条未将子公司责任与母公司滥用公司人格行为挂钩,建议将"无条件母债子偿"纳入逆向揭纱范围.法院即使适用逆向揭纱规则,也要将副作用降至最低.法院要严格把握人格混同过错、侵害事实、损害后果与因果关系等构成要件,竭尽法律救济规则,尊重公司的生存权和发展权.法院应优先穷尽债权人保护的常态化替代救济,包括股权执行、代位权、撤销权、代理规则、替代责任、共同侵权责任、担保责任与债务加入.为预防股东见利忘义的道德风险,我国应确认外部逆向揭纱,原则上不允许内部逆向揭纱.
Article 23 of the Company Law has not yet comprehensively and systematically recognized the reverse veil-piercing rule;it only contains elements of reverse veil-piercing in the consolidated veil-piercing rule for corporate groups introduced in paragraph 2.Based on the principles of good faith,fairness,and prohibition of abuse of rights,the legitimacy of the reverse veil-piercing rule should be recognized,while maintaining a high degree of restraint in its application.Giv-en that Article 7 of the Judicial Interpretation on Enterprise Restructuring fails to link subsidiary liability to the parent com-pany's abuse of corporate personality,it is advisable to incorporate"unconditional satisfaction of parent company debts by the subsidiary"into the scope of reverse veil-piercing.Even when applying the reverse veil-piercing rule,courts should minimize its adverse effects.Courts must strictly adhere to the constituent elements,including the fault of personality confu-sion,the fact of infringement,the resulting damage,and the causal relationship,exhaust other legal remedies,and respect the corporate right to survival and development.Courts should prioritize exhausting standard alternative remedies for creditor protection,including enforcement against equity interests,subrogation rights,rescission rights,agency rules,vicarious lia-bility,joint tort liability,guaranty liability,and debt assumption.To prevent the moral hazard of shareholders prioritizing profit over integrity,China should recognize external reverse veil-piercing while,in principle,disallowing internal reverse veil-piercing.