军事知识服务平台
案外人救济之诉的现实困境与体系整合
Research on the Dilemmas and Integration of the Action for Remedy of Third Parties in China
摘要 我国民事诉讼立法经过历次修改形成了现行的三种案外人救济之诉,即执行异议之诉、案外人再审申请与第三人撤销之诉并存的制度格局.在认可现行立法方案具有民主立法原则意义上的正当性的同时,也应意识到由此导致了司法权威消解、程序功能重叠以及审判资源浪费的现实困境.为厘清各种救济程序间的关系,应当通过解释论设置明确的区分标准,将是否存在执行程序设置为形式要件,将是否可认定错误裁判损害案外人利益设置为实质要件,从而寻求案外人救济之诉的体系整合.实质要件中对案外人的损害应严格限制于诈害诉讼、履行不能及特定风险三种情形.最终,在形式与实质要件交叉而成的坐标系"四象限"中,应当分别适用案外人申请再审、第三人撤销之诉、另行起诉与执行异议之诉.
Abstract:
Through successive amendments to China's civil procedure legislation,the current three types of third-party remedial litigation have been established,forming an institutional pattern where the Litigation of Objec-tion to Execution,third-party application for retrial,and Third-Party Revocation Action coexist.While ac-knowledging the legitimacy of this legislation in the sense of the principle of democratic legislation-as it a-ligns with the traditional notion of"adapting to judicial reality"and responds to the social need of cracking down on false litigation-we should also recognize the practical problems arising therefrom,including the e-rosion of judicial authority,overlapping of procedural functions,and waste of judicial resources.To clarify the relationships among these procedures,clear distinction criteria should be established through interpretive the-ory:the existence of enforcement proceedings shall serve as the formal element,and the ascertainability of an erroneous judgment infringing on the third party's interests shall serve as the substantive element-thereby accomplishing the systematic integration of third-party remedial litigation.The substantive element shall be strictly limited to three scenarios:fraudulent litigation,impossibility of performance,and specific risk.It is noteworthy that,regarding the third scenario(specific risk),judicial practice and the Interpretation on Litiga-tion of Objection to Execution have restricted the circumstances applicable to third-party applications for re-trial,making its scope formally narrower than that of the Third-Party Revocation Action.Ultimately,within the coordinate"four quadrants"formed by the intersection of formal and substantive elements,the third-party application for retrial,Third-Party Revocation Action,institution of a separate lawsuit,and Litigation of Ob-jection to Execution shall be applied respectively.
刊 名 法学家 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (2)
机标分类号: D925.1 D295.1 D632.9
在线出版日期: 2026年5月8日