摘要
事先合宪性审查在世界范围内有三种模式,分别是在立法起草阶段、立法审议阶段和通过后公布前的审查.从各国事先合宪性审查的实践来看,事先合宪性审查有咨询型、惯例型和效力型之分,但受限于事先审查机构组成人员的法律素养,芬兰模式的宪法委员会和法国模式的宪法委员会都需要得到辅助人员和外部专家的协助.传统观点认为,事先合宪性审查与立法审议很难区分或者事先合宪性审查主要是一种自我监督的观点可能无法成立.从审查的功能来讲,事先合宪性审查仍然具有异体监督的性质.无论是荷兰模式、芬兰模式中对起草机关的监督还是法国模式中对制定机关的监督,事先合宪性审查都可以发挥促进依宪立法的重要作用.但是必须看到,事先合宪性审查是立法在没有适用的情形下进行的,故审查偏重字面违宪,无法取代偏重适用违宪的事后合宪性审查.这可以从存在事先合宪性审查制度的国家都有事后合宪性审查制度得到印证.我国的事先合宪性审查需要在解决审查对象的广泛性、审查程序的公开性、审查结论的有效性上着手,并注重与事后备案审查的衔接.
There are three models of ex ante constitutional review worldwide:review during the legislative drafting stage,review during the legislative deliberation stage,and review before enactment.From the practice of ex ante constitutional review across countries,it can be categorized into advisory,customary,and mandatory types.However,constrained by the legal expertise of ex ante institutions,constitutional councils in the Finnish model and the French model require assistance from auxiliary personnel and external experts.The traditional view that ex ante constitutional review is difficult to distinguish from legislative deliberation or primarily serves as self-supervision may not hold.Functionally,ex ante constitutional review retains the nature of heteronomous oversight.Whether it involves supervision of drafting bodies in the Dutch or Finnish models or of legislative bodies in the French model,ex ante constitutional review can play a crucial role in promoting legislation in accordance with the Constitution.However,it must be recognized that ex ante constitutional review occurs when legislation is not yet applicable,thus favoring facial challenges and cannot replace ex post review,which prioritizes as-applied challenges.This is corroborated by the existence of ex post constitutional review systems in countries with ex ante review mechanisms.China's ex ante constitutional review must address the breadth of review subjects,the openness of review procedures,and the validity of review conclusions,while emphasizing coordination with filing and reviews.