军事知识服务平台
民营经济保护视角下非法经营同类营业罪行为主体的解释论展开
Interpretation on the Subject of the Crime of Operating Similar Businesses from the Perspective of Private Economy Protection
摘要 《中华人民共和国刑法修正案(十二)》将非法经营同类营业罪的行为主体扩大至"其他公司、企业的董事、监事、高级管理人员",与新《公司法》确立的竞业禁止义务主体实现同步.主体范围的扩大易导致本罪的扩张适用,理论层面的扩张解释亦将加剧民营企业家面临的刑事追诉风险.《刑法》与《公司法》的联动修订旨在强化对公司、企业内部人员背信行为的惩治力度,营造良好营商环境,但应保持合理限度,避免刑事手段干预经济纠纷.在新《公司法》背景下,应明确非法经营同类营业罪第1款及第2款规范本质的同一性与适用逻辑的差异性.对本罪行为主体范围的解释论塑造,需依托《公司法》及相关法律规范,准确区分《刑法》中"国有公司、企业"与"其他公司、企业"的界限,明确"事实董事、影子董事"的主体资格,并严格限定"高级管理人员"的范围,实现有效刑事治理与助推民营经济持续、健康、高质量发展的有机统一.
Abstract:
Amendment Ⅻ to the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China has expanded the subjects of the Crime of Operating Similar Businesses to directors,supervisors,and administrative officers of private enterprises,synchronizing with the new Company Law.However,the expansion of the punishment scope is likely to lead to the improper judicial expansion of the application of this crime,and the expansive interpretation of the subject of this crime at the theoretical level will in turn exacerbate the criminal prosecution risks confronted by private entrepreneurs.By contrast,the coordinated amendment of the Criminal Law and the Company Law is designed to strengthen the punishment for the acts of"harming the enterprise for personal gain"committed by internal personnel of companies and enterprises and foster a sound business environment,while strictly prohibiting the improper intervention in economic disputes through criminal means.In the context of the new Company Law,it is essential to clarify the unity in the normative essence and the differences in the applicability logic between Article 1 and Article 2 of the Crime of Operating Similar Businesses.Accordingly,the doctrinal construction of the subject of the crime shall be anchored in the Company Law and its supporting legal norms.Specifically,the boundary between"state-owned companies and enterprises"and"other companies and enterprises"shall be demarcated by means of a typological differentiation method.In the meantime,the subject qualification of"de facto directors and shadow directors"shall be clearly defined,and the scope of identification of"administrative officers"shall be strictly circumscribed to preclude any expansive interpretation that runs counter to the legislative intent,thereby achieving the organic unity of effectively punishing acts of"harming the enterprise for personal gain"and advancing the sustainable,healthy,and high-quality development of the private economy.
刊 名 法学论坛 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 41(4)
分类号: D914
机标分类号: D924 F279.246 F832.3
在线出版日期: 2026年8月12日
基金项目: 21FXA004:国家社会科学基金TJFXQN22-002:天津市哲学社会科学规划课题青年项目,