军事知识服务平台
论商业秘密法益属性下侵权举证责任分配的体系化改进
On the Systematic Improvement of the Allocation of Burden of Proof for Trade Secret Infringement from the Perspective of the Legal Interest Attribute of Trade Secrets
摘要 侵害商业秘密举证责任分配受商业秘密性质的实质影响,应在坚持商业秘密属法益而非权利的基础上,采行为法规制路径,协同吸收占有理论予以体系化改进.商业秘密构成要件举证之间存在牵连关系,保密性与秘密性互为手段与目的形成验证闭环,合理的保密措施可为秘密性认定提供支撑,秘密性的存续反向印证保密措施的有效性.价值性以秘密性为前置基础,需实质审查实用性以及涉案信息与竞争优势的因果关系.权利人信息来源作为确认其主体适格的关键要点,同时构成"接触可能性加实质相同"推定规则的适用前提.未来立法,亟待细化要件联动审查标准、明确初步举证范围以及限制适用侵权推定规则,重构覆盖商业秘密构成、利益归属及侵权行为举证的完整路径,适配数字时代技术迭代下商业秘密保护的现实需求.
Abstract:
The allocation of tort evidential burden for trade secret infringement is substantially affected by the legal nature of trade secrets.On the premise that trade secrets are defined as legal interests rather than statutory rights,a conduct-based regulation path should be adopted,and systematic improvement can be achieved by collaboratively applying the possession theory.There is an internal correlation in the proof of each constituent element of trade secrets.Confidentiality and secrecy serve as mutual means and ends to form a complete verification loop.Reasonable confidentiality measures can support the identification of secrecy,and the continuous existence of secrecy can inversely confirm the validity of confidentiality measures.As secrecy constitutes the prerequisite for valuability,it is necessary to conduct substantive examination on practical utility and clarify the causal connection between the involved information and competitive advantages.The lawful source of a right holder's information is essential to confirm procedural qualification,and also serves as the applicable premise of the presumption rule of"access possibility plus substantial similarity".Future legislation shall refine the interactive review standards of constituent elements,clarify the scope of preliminary evidential burden,and restrict the application of infringement presumption rules.It is essential to reconstruct an integrated proof path covering the identification of trade secrets,confirmation of interest ownership and proof of tortious conducts,so as to meet the practical demands of trade secret protection against the background of technological iteration in the digital era.
刊 名 法学论坛 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 41(4)
分类号: D923.4
机标分类号: D922.294 TP319 F272.3
在线出版日期: 2026年8月12日
基金项目: 25BFX085:国家社会科学基金,