军事知识服务平台
也谈供卡人掐卡、取款的行为性质
摘要 在供卡人将银行卡提供给用卡人正常使用(不用来从事违法犯罪活动)的场合,供卡人以非法占有该银行卡账户中用卡人存储的钱款为目的而掐卡(挂失旧卡补办新卡),是为取款制造条件的诈骗犯罪预备行为.掐卡行为虽然会损害用卡人"可以随时取款或转账"的利益,但这种利益不属于财产罪侵害对象的财产性利益,更不可能成为盗窃罪侵害的对象.掐卡后未来得及取款即告案发的,可能成立诈骗(预备)罪,但不可能构成盗窃罪.在供卡人将银行卡提供给用卡人用于电信诈骗的场合,供卡人明知其银行卡账户钱款来源于电信诈骗犯罪而掐卡,对这种行为定性,应根据其提供银行卡时,对用卡人将要用来从事何种活动的主观认识、以及其实施掐卡行为的目的动机,分别情形得出不同的定性结论.供卡人以非法占有银行卡账户中的钱款为目的而掐卡并取款的,无论是在用卡人正常使用银行卡、还是将银行卡用于电信诈骗的场合,也不论是在银行柜台、还是自动柜员机上取款,数额较大的,均构成诈骗罪.
Abstract:
In the case that the card holder provides the bank card to the actual card user for normal use(without engaging in illegal activities),the card holder illegally possesses the money that the card user deposited in the card holder's bank card ac-count by cutting off the card(reporting the loss of the old card and replacing it with a new card),which is a preparatory activity of the crime of fraud to create conditions for withdrawal.Although the behavior of cutting off the card may harm the interests of card users who can withdraw or transfer money at any time,this interest does not belong to the property interests of the victim of property crimes,and it is even less likely to become the victim of theft crimes.If a person commits a crime without being able to withdraw money after cutting off the card,it may constitute the crime of fraud(preparatory),but it cannot constitute the crime of theft.In the case that the card holder provides a bank card to the card user for telecommunications fraud crime,and the card holder knows that the funds in his bank card account are sourced from telecommunications fraud crimes and cuts off the card,the characterization of this behavior should be based on his subjective understanding of what activities the card user will engage in when providing the bank card,as well as his motives and purposes to cut off the card.Different qualitative conclusions should be drawn for each situation.If the card holder illegally cuts off the card and withdraws money from a bank card account for the purpose of illegally possessing the funds,whether the card user is using the bank card normally,or using the bank card for telecommunications fraud crime,or withdrawing large amounts at a bank counter or ATM,it constitutes the crime of fraud.
刊 名 法学评论 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 44(2)
机标分类号: D924.11 F832.2 TP393.08
在线出版日期: 2026年4月20日
基金项目: GJ2025B10:最高人民检察院检察理论研究课题网络环境下的诈骗犯罪研究项目,