军事知识服务平台
论意思自治在税收征管中的适用及其限制
摘要 预约定价、税收遵从协议、纳税担保、税务和解乃至税收"协议"等情形均蕴含意思自治的因素.在"包税合同"和第三人提供纳税担保的场合,意思自治还延伸约束第三人.公法和私法的区分不宜绝对化,意思自治亦不当然具有私法属性,并非绝缘于税收征管实践.准确理解税收法定的意涵,才能判明各类涉意思自治情形的合法性.准确理解意思自治的内涵和外延,才能避免其在税收征管中被泛化适用.税收征管中的意思自治不得违反强制性规定,且该处强制性规定的范围较之民法场域更宽.与此同时,即便可适用意思自治,也要立足于税法的属性和税务机关的高权地位,从实体和程序维度加以规制.
Abstract:
Scenarios such as advance pricing arrangements,tax compliance agreements,tax guarantees,tax settlements,and even tax"agreements"all embody elements of party autonomy.In the context of"tax farming contracts"and tax guaran-tees provided by third parties,party autonomy further extends to bind such third parties.The distinction between public law and private law should not be absolutized;party autonomy does not inherently possess exclusive private law attributes,nor is it insulated from the practice of tax administration.Only by accurately understanding the connotation of the principle of taxation by law can the legality of various scenarios involving party autonomy be determined.Similarly,accurately grasping the conno-tation and denotation of party autonomy is essential to prevent its indiscriminate application in tax administration.Party auton-omy in tax administration must not violate mandatory provisions,the scope of which is broader in this context than in the do-main of civil law.Furthermore,even where party autonomy is applicable,it must be regulated from both substantive and pro-cedural dimensions,grounded in the nature of tax law and the authoritative status of tax authorities.
刊 名 法学评论 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 44(2)
机标分类号: D923.6 F812.42 F270
在线出版日期: 2026年4月20日
基金项目: 25BFX055:国家社会科学基金,