摘要
在《企业破产法》修订与《生态环境法典》编纂的双重背景下,环境债权在破产程序中的清偿顺位问题成为连接破产法与环境法的关键枢纽.通过解构"公平清偿"与"环境优先"、"程序终结"与"持续义务"、"私权保护"与"公共利益"三重制度逻辑冲突,可建立公平清偿、可计量性与类型区分三项环境债权清偿顺位构建的基本原则.基于此,环境债权应区分为人身损害、财产损害与生态环境损害三类,分别匹配差异化顺位.其中,人身损害债权与职工债权同阶,且在关联财产上优先于担保权;财产损害债权原则上归入普通债权,仅在关联自然资源永续利用时具有有限优先性;生态环境损害债权劣后于人身损害债权但优先于普通债权,且仅在关联财产上优先于担保权.相关配套制度应通过或有债权分层处理机制、董事环境责任扩张、环境责任保险与环保基金构建风险分散网络,形成"主辅互补"的清偿保障体系.这一顺位构建既落实《民法典》绿色原则,又维护破产法功能,为破产法的绿色化转型提供制度范本.
Against the dual backdrop of the revision of the Enterprise Bankruptcy Law and the compilation of the Ecological and Environmental Code,the priority of environmental claims in bankruptcy proceedings has become a pivotal nexus between bank-ruptcy law and environmental law.By deconstructing three layers of institutional tension—"fair distribution"versus"environ-mental priority""procedural finality"versus"ongoing obligations"and"private-rights protection"versus"public-interest protection"—this study proposes three foundational principles for structuring the priority of environmental claims:fair distribu-tion,measurability,and type differentiation.On that basis,environmental claims should be categorized into three types-per-sonal injury claims,property damage claims,and ecological/environmental damage claims and assigned differentiated priority rules.Specifically,personal injury claims should rank on par with employee claims and,with respect to directly related assets,take precedence over secured creditors;property damage claims should generally be treated as ordinary unsecured claims,but may receive limited priority when they concern the sustainable use of natural resources;ecological/environmental remediation claims should rank below personal injury claims but above ordinary unsecured claims,and only take precedence over security in-terests insofar as they relate to the contaminated assets.Complementary measures,such as a layered handling mechanism for contingent environmental claims,expansion of directors' environmental liability,environmental liability insurance,and envi-ronmental funds,which should form a risk-sharing network that supplements the priority regime.This priority framework both implements the Civil Code's green principles and preserves the core functions of bankruptcy law,offering an institutional model for the"greening"of bankruptcy law.