摘要
合同具有治理交易的功能,智能合约是对交易的一种治理创新.智能合约的自动履行极大降低了事中交易成本——合同履行成本,却也使智能合约丧失了合同履行的灵活性,使智能合约不适于治理继续性交易.在治理交易的过程中,智能合约将交易成本从事中推向了事前和事后.事前阶段,代码的精确性、当事人的匿名性、语义合同向智能合约转换的不完全性以及避免代码漏洞的努力,这些都推高了智能合约的缔约成本.事后阶段,去中心化的链上争议解决方式规则不明确,导致智能合约的争议解决结果难预期;而选择链下的传统法院诉讼方式,相较于语义合同,智能合约争议解决成本更高.智能合约的去中心化特征意味着标准化条款只能有限缓和缔约成本,预言机(外部数据机)可以一定程度缓和而不能有效解决智能合约的履行刚性,语义合同与智能合约构成的混合合同可以有效降低智能合约的缔约成本和争议解决成本.
Contracts have the function of governing transactions,and Smart Contract is an innovative governance of transactions.The automated execution of Smart Contract greatly reduces the costs of contract performance,but also makes Smart Contract lose the flexibility of contract performance,rendering Smart Contract unsuitable for governing continuing trans-actions.Although Smart Contract can reduce the costs of contract performance in the event-stage,it pushes the transactions costs to the pre-event stage and the post-event stage.In the pre-event stage,the accuracy of the Smart Contract code,the anonymity of the parties,the incompleteness of the conversion from Semantic Contract to Smart Contract,and the avoidance of code vulnerabilities all push up the contracting costs.In the post-event stage,the rules of the decentralized on-chain dispute resolution of Smart Contract are uncertain,and the results of dispute resolution are difficult to predict.If dispute resolution of Smart Contract chooses the traditional court litigation off-chain,compared with the Semantic Contract,it will have a higher costs of dispute resolution.How to mitigate the transaction costs of Smart Contract?Decentralized feature of Smart Contract means that standardized terms of Smart Contract can only mitigate contracting costs in a limited way,Oracle can only mitigate the rigidity of Smart Contract performance to a certain extent but cannot effectively solve it,the hybrid contract composed of Se-mantic Contract and Smart Contract can effectively reduce the contracting costs and dispute resolution costs of Smart Contract.