军事知识服务平台
论我国不方便法院条款适用的裁量空间
摘要 我国《民事诉讼法》第282条载明不方便法院原则,其中"可以裁定驳回起诉"的表述所包含的裁量空间被司法实践持续忽视,故有必要对其范围与标准进行规范化阐释.为此,需要先明确我国不方便法院条款的规范目的及适用次序.就规范目的而言,对外关系法视域下,不方便法院条款的便利性与实质正义目的需扩张以兼容管辖协调与管辖竞争功能.就适用次序而言,不方便法院条款应遵循程序化决策逻辑,按"否决式要件—狭义便利性判断—实质正义目的"的次序展开.依照这一逻辑,在满足第282条第1款全部要件时,法院的自由裁量空间属于实质正义的考量范围.具体而言,法院应在两种必要情形下激活这一裁量空间:第一,弱势一方当事人需要紧迫救济,且外法域法院缺乏程序性保障;第二,外国歧视性限制措施导致我国实体海外民事利益受损,有必要积极行使管辖权以保障我国发展利益与当事人合法权益.
Abstract:
Under Article 282 of the Civil Procedure Law,the forum non conveniens clause in China employs the wording"may dismiss the action"when all requisite conditions are met.While this phrasing implies a margin of discretion according to legal interpretation,such discretion has been persistently overlooked in judicial practice;consequently,a normative elucidation of its scope and standards is necessary.To this end,it is essential to first clarify the normative purposes and the application se-quence of China's forum non conveniens clause.Regarding normative purposes,from the perspective of foreign relations law,the objectives of convenience and substantive justice must be expanded to incorporate the functions of jurisdictional coordination and jurisdictional competition.Regarding the application sequence,the clause should adhere to a programmed decision-making logic,proceeding through the order of"veto elements-narrow convenience assessment-substantive justice objectives".Fol-lowing this logic,when all conditions in the first paragraph of Article 280 are met,the courts remaining discretionary space falls within the ambit of substantive justice considerations.Specifically,courts should activate this discretionary space in two necessa-ry scenarios:first,where a vulnerable party requires urgent relief and the foreign forum lacks procedural safeguards;and sec-ond,where foreign discriminatory restrictive measures impair the overseas civil interests of Chinese entities,necessitating the active exercise of jurisdiction to safeguard China's development interests and the legitimate rights of the parties involved.
刊 名 法学评论 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 44(2)
机标分类号: D925.1 F20 F810.6
在线出版日期: 2026年4月20日
基金项目: 23BFX194:国家社会科学基金,