Legal Foundations and Institutional Design of Public Security Violation Records Sealing in China
摘要
新修订的《治安管理处罚法》增设了治安违法记录封存制度,该制度对治安违法行为人的权利保障具有非常重要的意义.从正当性依据看,目前的理论研究主要依附于轻罪记录封存对治安违法记录封存进行"举重以明轻"的立法类推,这种外部式证成存在不足,至多能解决制度的逻辑正当性问题.出于基本权利和公共利益的考量,对治安违法记录封存进行立法衡量的内部式证成,更具有现实意义.从制度层面看,治安违法记录的封存范围不仅应包括治安处罚决定,还应包括治安处罚作出过程的所有信息;有权查询的国家机关不应仅限于监察机关、法院、检察院、公安机关和国家安全机关,还应扩大至其他有办案权力的执法机关;有关单位的查询依据应包括法律、行政法规和部门规章,不包括地方性法规、地方政府规章和其他规范性文件;在查询技术规则上,应严格控制查询范围并设定保密义务,设置安全密钥以隔离敏感数据,通过警务区块链技术追溯访问记录并建立异常访问预警机制.
The revised Public Security Administration Punishments Law has introduced a record-sealing system for public security violations.This system is significant for protecting the lawful rights and interests of offenders.Existing scholarship primarily justifies it by drawing paral-lels between the sealing of records for minor offenses and the sealing for public order violations,but such external justification is insufficient and can only address the issue of the system's logical legitimacy.A more meaningful approach is to provide an internal justification grounded in funda-mental rights and the public interest.Institutionally,the scope of sealing records should include not only the public security punishment decisions but also all the information generated during the process of imposing such punishment.The entities authorized to access such records should not be confined to supervisory commissions,people's courts,people's procuratorates,public secur-ity organs,and state security organs,but should extend to other law enforcement agencies with case-handling powers.The legal basis for such access should be limited to laws,administrative regulations,and departmental rules,excluding local regulations,local government rules,and other normative documents.Regarding technical rules for inquires,the scope of access should be strictly controlled and confidentiality obligations imposed;security keys should be used to isolate sensitive data;and police blockchain technology should be employed to make access records traceable and to establish an abnormal-access alert mechanism.