Systematic Reflection on Criminal Electronic Data:Regulations in the Context of the Fourth Revision of the Criminal Procedure Law
摘要
经过20多年的发展,我国刑事电子数据规范已经形成一个初步的规范群.但刑事电子数据规范群还面临着体系化程度不足的问题:整体上游离于《刑事诉讼法》之外,电子数据规范的颁布由相关部门主导,刑事电子数据规范各部分相互脱节现象严重.这一规制格局已经显露出诸多弊端,包括电子数据规范的合法性严重不足、电子数据取证权力的程序控制不足以及相对人权利保障的缺位.应该以《刑事诉讼法》第四次修改为契机,对我国刑事电子数据规范加以体系化重塑,实现《刑事诉讼法》与其下位法的良性互动.在《刑事诉讼法》层面,应该从法律保留的角度确立电子数据取证的必要性原则和电子数据的分级分类制度,在取证程序上要强化对电子数据取证的分类控制,确立电子数据非法证据排除规则并赋予其合法性保障功能.在此基础上,形成以《刑事诉讼法》为上位法宏观指导,司法解释及其他规范性文件具体落实的电子数据规范体系.
After more than two decades of development,China's criminal electronic data standards have formed a preliminary normative cluster.However,this cluster still suffers from a lack of systematic integration:it is largely detached from the Criminal Procedure Law,with the promulgation of electronic data standards being led by relevant departments,and there is a serious disconnection between various parts of the criminal electronic data standards.Such a reg-ulatory framework has revealed numerous drawbacks,including the serious deficiencies in the le-gitimacy of electronic data standards themselves,insufficient procedural control over the power of electronic data evidence collection,and the absence of protection for the rights of the opposing party.Taking the fourth amendment to the Criminal Procedure Law as an opportunity,China's criminal electronic data standards should be systematically reshaped to achieve positive interac-tion between the Criminal Procedure Law and its subordinate laws.At the level of the Criminal Procedure Law,the principle of necessity for electronic data evidence collection and a grading and classification system for electronic data should be established.In terms of evidence collection procedures,it is necessary to strengthen the classification control of electronic data evidence col-lection,establish exclusionary rules for illegal electronic data evidence,endowing it with the function of ensuring legal validity.On this basis,an electronic data standards system should be formed,with the Criminal Procedure Law providing overarching guidance as the superior law,and judicial interpretations and other normative documents serving to implement its provisions in detail.