军事知识服务平台
信息网络侵权诉讼地域管辖规则的反思与修正
Reflection and Revision of the Territorial Jurisdiction Rules of Information Network Infringement Litigation
摘要 信息网络侵权行为的跨地域性、隐蔽性和技术性等特征使侵权行为实施地与损害结果发生地的分布呈现复杂性,将以物理空间为中心的传统侵权诉讼地域管辖规则适用于信息网络侵权诉讼面临严峻挑战.我国信息网络侵权诉讼地域管辖的规范逻辑存在明显冲突,在实践中表现出信息网络侵权行为认定标准不一、网络服务器所在地理解各异及信网权侵权诉讼管辖依据存在分歧等.困境产生的原因是未明确信息网络侵权纠纷的特点却将传统侵权诉讼管辖规则机械地适用于信息网络侵权案件.鉴于此,应坚持"原告就被告"地域管辖一般规则不动摇及管辖连接点与纠纷事实具有密切联系的原则,通过明确信息网络侵权行为的概念、设定类型化管辖规则、厘清侵权行为地的识别标准和优化管辖权异议审查机制,构建既尊重信息网络侵权纠纷的本质特征,又符合民事诉讼管辖基本理论的管辖制度体系.
Abstract:
The cross-regional,invisible,and technical nature of information network in-fringement results in a complex distribution between the place where the infringement is commit-ted and the place where the damage occurs.The application of traditional territorial jurisdiction rules for infringement litigation centered on physical space to information network infringement lit-igation is facing severe challenges.There are obvious conflicts in the normative logic governing jurisdiction over information network infringement litigation in China.In practice,these conflicts manifest as inconsistent standards for identifying network infringements,different understandings of the location of network servers,and divergences regarding the basis for jurisdiction in such ca-ses.The predicaments arise from the failure to clearly identify the characteristics of information network infringement disputes while mechanically applying traditional jurisdiction rules of in-fringement litigation to information network infringement cases.In view of this,on the basis of adhering to the general principle of territorial jurisdiction that the plaintiff shall follow the defend-ant and the principle that jurisdictional connecting factors must be closely related to the facts of the dispute,it is necessary to clarify the definition of information network infringement,establish categorized jurisdictional rules for disputes,define the criteria for identifying the place of in-fringement,and optimize the review mechanism for jurisdictional objections to construct a juris-dictional framework that respects the essential attributes of information network infringement dis-putes and conforms to the fundamental principles of civil procedural jurisdiction.
刊 名 法学杂志 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 47(5)
机标分类号: D925.1 TP393 F062.5
在线出版日期: 2026年10月13日
基金项目: 22BFXJ01:山东省社会科学规划研究重点项目,