Proof of Algorithmic Tacit Collusion:From the Dilemma of Imputation to the Construction of Evidence Rules
摘要
在反垄断法理论与执法实践中,默示共谋始终是一个复杂且极具争议的议题.数字经济时代,算法深度嵌入市场竞争进程,催生算法默示共谋新型样态,对传统反垄断规制框架构成显著挑战.在算法默示共谋的规制实践中,技术壁垒导致直接证据普遍缺乏,因此,构建以间接证据为核心的证明体系成为突破当前规制困境的可行方案.根据证据来源与证明作用的不同,可将间接证据类型化为三类:信息交换、数据传输等交流证据;算法协同行为、算法惩罚与监督行为等行为证据;市场结构证据等环境证据.单一类型间接证据的证明力有限,无法独立完成共谋成立的推定.对此,在反垄断执法与司法实践中,可结合单项效力观与整体效力观的适用优势,将各类间接证据有机结合、相互印证,构建严密的证据链条.在证据认定过程中,既要审查单项间接证据的独立证明价值,也要综合评估证据群的整体证明效果,逐步构建统一、规范的证据规则体系.
In the theory and enforcement practice of anti-monopoly law,tacit collusion has long been a complex and highly controversial issue.In the era of the digital economy,algorithms are deeply embedded in market competition processes,giving rise to new forms of algorithmic tac-it collusion that pose substantial challenges to the traditional anti-monopoly regulatory frame-work.In the regulatory practice concerning algorithmic tacit collusion,technical barriers often re-sult in a general lack of direct evidence.For this reason,the establishment of a proof system cen-tered on circumstantial evidence has become a viable solution to overcome the prevailing regulato-ry dilemma.Based on their sources and probative value,circumstantial evidence can be divided into three categories:communications evidence,such as information exchange and data transmis-sion;behavioral evidence including algorithmic coordination,algorithmic penalties,and monito-ring conduct;and contextual evidence represented by market structure.Any single category of circumstantial evidence carries limited probative weight and cannot independently sustain the pre-sumption of collusion.To address this concern,in anti-monopoly enforcement and judicial prac-tice,the respective strengths of the individual-effect and aggregate-effect perspectives can be combined.By integrating different categories of circumstantial evidence for mutual corroboration,a rigorous chain of evidence can be constructed.Throughout the evidence assessment process,it is necessary not only to examine the independent probative value of each individual piece of cir-cumstantial evidence,but also to comprehensively assess the overall probative effect of the evi-dence cluster,thereby gradually developing a unified and standardized system of evidentiary rules.