军事知识服务平台
调解规避:司法责任制下法官的行动逻辑与制度调适
Mediation Avoidance:The Action Logic of Judges and Institutional Adjustment under the Judicial Accountability System
摘要 法院调解作为中国司法制度的特色实践,兼具中华优秀传统文化标识与现代治理的正当性.然而,从实践的情况来看,法官基于风险最小化逻辑,呈现出将案件从调解导向判决的"趋判避调"行为取向.这并非法官个人偏好的简单呈现,而是司法责任制作为影响法官行动逻辑的最大制度变量所产生的影响.由于责任风险的非对称性分配、法官裁判者与调解者双重身份的角色冲突,以及数智化治理下的效率规训等结构性压力,法官的调解意愿被系统性抑制.在正视判决与调解两种解纷方式差异的前提下,应坚持司法责任制改革的方向,回归对制度体系适配性的审视.从重塑责任分担机制、优化法官角色配置、构建差异化考核评价机制等层面进行系统性调适,以消解法官的后顾之忧,使其回归调解优先的制度轨道,矫正以判决规避调解的错位格局.
Abstract:
Court mediation occupies a central place in China's judicial tradition,bridging cultural legacies with modern state governance.However,in practice,judges who guided by a logic of risk minimization tend to steer cases toward judgments rather than mediation,exhibiting a behavioral orientation of"judgment preference over mediation".This pattern cannot be reduced to individual inclination;rather,it reflects structural constraints inherent in the reform design.Due to the asymmetric risk allocation,the role conflict arising from judges' dual identities as ad-judicators and mediators,and structural pressures such as efficiency-driven discipline under digital and intelligent governance,judges' willingness to mediate is systematically suppressed.Recognizing the functional distinctions between these two dispute-resolution modes,the paper argues for a recalibration of the reform framework.Systemic adjustments should be made to allevi-ate judges' concerns,including reshaping the mechanism for sharing responsibility,optimizing the allocation of judicial roles,and establishing a differentiated performance evaluation system.Thereby,it can bring those concerns back to the institutional track of prioritizing mediation,and correct the misalignment where judgments are used to circumvent mediation.
刊 名 法学杂志 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 47(5)
机标分类号: TP181 D925.1 G641
在线出版日期: 2026年10月13日