Systematic Reconstruction and Normative Expression of Economic Law Rights in the Context of Codification
摘要
经济法权利是经济法的重要内容,制定经济法典需要构建合理的权利体系框架.传统经济法权利体系化理论采取"主体—权利"的权利外部归属方法,形成"特定身份主体+权利"和"特定行为(主体)+权利"的两类权利表现形式,虽可维护经济法规范中权利要素与主体要素的逻辑一致性,彰显经济法权利之于特定主体的独特功能,但也存在一定局限性.为了进一步厘清经济法各项权利之间的结构关系,揭示权利配置的依据,可以拓展采用"权利—权利"的权利内部关系方法,将其作为经济法权利体系化的新路径,并依据"目标—手段"分析框架,将各种权利划分为目标性权利和手段性权利.其中,目标性权利可以概括为经济发展权、经济分配权和经济安全权,手段性权利可以划分为多层次的抽象程度不同的权利.在经济法典中,可分别以状态和行为为载体表达目标性权利和手段性权利,总则部分规定目标性权利以及重要性明显、抽象程度高的手段性权利;分则部分规定特定领域的目标性权利、特定领域抽象程度较低的具体且重要的手段性权利,并做好与授权规定的衔接.
Economic law rights constitute a crucial component of economic law,and the for-mulation of an economic code requires establishing a rational framework for the rights system.Traditional theories on the systematization of economic law rights adopt an external attribution ap-proach based on"subjects-rights",resulting in two forms of rights expression:"subjects with specific status+rights"and"specific actions(subjects)+rights".While this approach main-tains logical consistency between rights elements and subject elements within economic legal norms and highlights the unique functions of economic law rights for specific subjects,it also has certain limitations.To further clarify the structural relationships among various economic law rights and reveal the basis for rights allocation,we can expand the approach by adopting an inter-nal relational method based on"rights-rights"as a new pathway toward systematizing economic law rights.Using the"goal-means"analytical framework,economic law rights can be catego-rized into goal-oriented rights and means-oriented rights.Among these,goal-oriented rights may be summarized as the right to economic development,the right to economic distribution,and the right to economic security,while means-oriented rights can be divided into rights at multiple layers of abstraction.In the economic code,goal-oriented rights and means-oriented rights may be expressed through states and behaviors respectively.The general provisions section should establish goal-oriented rights as well as means-oriented rights that are clearly significant and highly abstract.The specific provisions section should address goal-oriented rights in particular fields,less abstract and concrete yet important means-oriented rights,while simultaneously en-suring proper coordination with authorization provisions.