军事知识服务平台
涉众型犯罪分案审理的规范化建构
A Normative Scheme of Separate Trial of Crimes Involving Multiple Parties——With the Further Amendment to the Criminal Procedure Law as the Background
摘要 涉众型犯罪分案审理属于《刑事诉讼法》再修改的一个重点事项.分案审理滥觞于我国治理大规模刑事案件的急切需求,同时因应了现代刑法中传统犯罪构成的变化.但将分案审理上升为法律制度时需破解主犯和从犯的地位作用模糊、前案裁判效力不当扩张、当事人质证权受损等现实难题.通过分析我国司法以及比较法中的分案审理可以发现,我国分案审理以效率导向和职权导向为基本机理,以最低限度权利保障为原则底线.本次修法应以此为基础规范化构建分案审理制度,解决分案审理中的相关问题,具体包括限缩分案审理适用前提,明确同案审理的一般原则,采取"先主犯、后从犯""先难后易"的分案方法,保障当事人的质证权、异议权等权利,规范不同案件审判人员的组成等.
Abstract:
The separate trial of crimes involving multiple parties is a key issue of the latest a-mendment to the Criminal Procedure Law.It originated from the urgent need to manage large-scale criminal cases in China,while also responding to the changes in traditional criminal ele-ments under modern criminal law.However,elevating the separate trial to a legal system needs to solve some problems,such as ambiguity regarding the status and roles of the principal and acces-sory offenders,improperly expanding the binding effect of previous judgments,and damaging the defendants' right to examine.By analyzing Chinese justice system and the separate trial in com-parative law,it can be found that the basic mechanism of separate trial is power-and-efficiency-oriented,with the minimum safeguards of rights as the basic principle.Based on the mecha-nism and principle,the further amendment of the Criminal Procedure Law can overcome the a-bove obstacles and establish a standardized system for separate trials.Specifically,this includes narrowing the conditions under which separate trials are applied,clarifying that joint crimes should be tried in the same trial,adopting the method of"accessory after the principal"and"easy cases after difficult ones",ensuring the full exercise of the defendants' rights such as right to cross-examine and right to objection,and regulating the composition of judges in separate ca-ses.
刊 名 法学杂志 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, 47(5)
机标分类号: D925.2 C931 D621.5
在线出版日期: 2026年10月13日
基金项目: :中国社会科学院党的创新理论专门研究机构建设专项,